Print the value of index0
  • Report:  #659356

Complaint Review: Aesthetic Facial Plastic Surgery PLLC

Aesthetic Facial Plastic Surgery, PLLC Dr. Philip Young, MD Dr Young has made my nose look worse than before the surgery and has not fixed my breathing function , Internet

  • Reported By:
    Steve — Seattle Washington United States of America
  • Submitted:
    Mon, November 08, 2010
  • Updated:
    Thu, February 17, 2011

I chose to go with Dr. Young because it appears that he is double board certified.  Also after observing my nose he was very confident that he could fix it.  This was my fourth nose surgery and it was a full reconstructive surgery using rib cartaledge.  Dr. Young claims that he has all the same training as the leading nose surgens in the world.


Two other things sealed the deal for me.  First, his price was pretty good compared to other private surgens, $7,800 total $4,400 going straight to him.  Now, having 3 previous failed surgerys I knew quite well the possibility of failure.  So I asked him what would happen if the surgery failed and how long it would take to know.  He said if the surgery failed that he would refund his cut ($4,400) and it would take about a year after the surgery to tell if it was successful or not.


The surgery took him four hours longer than he said it would (10 to 11 hours total).  He was supposed to collect the rib cartiledge via a 1/4 inch incision under my pectoral muscle like good surgeons do.  Instead, he cuts a 2 to 2 1/2 inch incision straight through my top left abdominal muscle.  Recovering from this was more painful than the nose reconstruction itself.


When he took the bandage off my nose it was HUGE.  I mean I looked scarey.  I couldn't even look at myself in the mirror.  The swelling has gone down a lot since then, but my nose is still very big and bulky.  The tip of my nose is a big glob of cartiledge, the right side of the nose is lower than the left side.  Here I am a year and a half later and my nose looks worse than before the surgery.


I asked Dr. Young for a refund and he says he never said anything about giving me a refund.  However, he would like to continue to "help" me by doing another surgery.  I told him that I would not let him do another surgery on me if he paid me 8 grand.


Dr. Young has no talent as a nose surgeon.  His talent is in deception.  Out of the four surgeons he is by far the worst.  I urge you to stay far away from this wolf in sheeps clothing.

2 Updates & Rebuttals


Steve

Seattle,
Washington,
USA

Dr. Young is a wonderful person

#3Author of original report

Thu, February 17, 2011

I would like to recant my previously posts and statements concerning Dr. Philip Young of Aesthetic Facial Plastic Surgery. After three prior failed rhinoplaty surgeries (from other prominent surgeons) before I sought Dr. Young’s services, Dr. Young did an exceptional job with what he could to repair the damage I suffered previously to my nose. I may have misplaced my frustration and unfairly characterized Dr. Young’s medical expertise and capabilities. I now have a better understanding of the surgery Dr. Young performed on me and I am prepared to recant my prior characterization of Dr. Young. Dr. Young is a wonderful person and I know that he strives to constantly improve and care for his patients. I was looking on his website and know that there are a lot of patients that truly adore Dr. Young. Here is a link to his testimonial page: http://www.drphilipyoung.com/about_testimonials.html.


Steve

Seattle,
Washington,
USA

Dr. Young botched my nose and lied to me about a refund for failed surgery

#3Author of original report

Wed, December 08, 2010

I chose to go with Dr. Young because it appears that he is double board certified.  Also after observing my nose he was very confident that he could fix it.  This was my fourth nose surgery and it was a full re constructive surgery using rib cartilage.  Dr. Young claims that he has all the same training as the leading nose surgeons in the world.


Two other things sealed the deal for me.  First, his price was pretty good compared to other private surgeons, $7,800 total $4,400 going straight to him.  Now, having 3 previous failed surgeries I knew quite well the possibility of failure.  So I asked him what would happen if the surgery failed and how long it would take to know.  He said if the surgery failed that he would refund his cut ($4,400) and it would take about a year after the surgery to tell if it was successful or not.


The surgery took him four hours longer than he said it would (10 to 11 hours total).  He was supposed to collect the rib cartilage via a 1/4 inch incision under my pectoral muscle like good surgeons do.  Instead, he cuts a 2 to 2 1/2 inch incision straight through my top left abdominal muscle.  Recovering from this was more painful than the nose reconstruction itself.


When he took the bandage off my nose it was HUGE.  I mean I looked scary.  I couldn't even look at myself in the mirror.  The swelling has gone down a lot since then, but my nose is still very big and bulky.  The tip of my nose is a big glob of cartilage, the right side of the nose is lower than the left side.  Here I am a year and a half later and my nose looks worse than before the surgery.


I asked Dr. Young for a refund and he says he never said anything about giving me a refund.  However, he would like to continue to "help" me by doing another surgery.  I told him that I would not let him do another surgery on me if he paid me 8 grand.


 Dr. Young's talent is in deception.  Out of the four surgeons he is the worst.  I urge you to stay away from this wolf in sheep's clothing.

Respond to this Report!