Complaint Review: rent a center

I RENTED A LAPTOP COMPUTER A A GIFT FOR MY GIRLFRIEND AND PAID FOR THE BENFITS PLUS WHICH STATED IN CONTRACT THAT IF IT WAS STOLEN IT WOULD BE REPLACED, MY GIRLFRIEND REPORTED IT STOLEN AND SAID SHE THOUGHT HER DAUGHTER MIGHT HAVE SOMETHING TO DO WITH IT BUT WAS NOT SURE AND BECAUSE SEH SAID THAT IN HER STATMENT THEY REFUSE TO REPLACE IT BUT STILL WANT ME TO PAY FOR IT. IAM STILL FIGHTING IT SAYING THAT IT SHOULD NOT MATTER IT WAS CLEARLY STOLEN AND THEY SHOULD REPLACE IT I PAID FOR THAT COVERAGE!!!!!!