Complaint Review: Tires Plus

On Dec 23, 2008, I went to Tires Plus Store #2050652 in Duluth Ga. to have my vehicle aligned. I had just replaced the upper and lower ball joints (I did the work) and knew the alignment was out. When I returned later, the manager, Mr. Deric Nagle said that I needed outer tie-rod ends and presented me with an estimate of $426.50 to replace the tie-rod ends and align the vehicle.

I bought the new ends and when I pulled the first end, it was evident that they were not bad at all. I already had both wheels off and it's no big deal to change ends and I intend to keep the vehicle, so I installed them anyway. The entire job took 1/2 hour. It is no big deal if you have the tools, and I do.

I took it back to Mr. Nagle and told him that I had installed them and also showed him the old tie-rod end and commented that I was not happy about spending $90.00 unnecessarily. They are only $45.00 each not the $99.74 each as in his estimate. By the way,my price was with a lifetime warranty.

He never checked the old tie rod end but immediately informed me that the alignment would be $74.99 instead of the $54.99 stated as standard alignment charge. Because, and I quote" I installed my own parts". I was being penalized because I did my own work. The parts totaled $90.00, not $199.48 and it only took 1/2 hour to install. At $202.19 for 1/2 hour of work, thats $404.28 per hr that I made.

When I picked up the vehicle, I explained my situation to the man who seemed to be in charge (Mr. Nagle was not there). I related my story to him (name unknown) and to his credit he reduced the price to the standard alighment charge.

In the lobby, there is a sign that says " 50% off on alignment upon APPLICATION for a Tires Plus credit card ". Note: the word application. It was very close to closing time but I said to give me an application. I was told that it only applied upon ACCEPTANCE. I said, so call and I will wait. This did not go over well, but he did call and I was accepted for a credit line of $1,800.00.

So he reduced the price to $29.99. That price from $426.50. No thanks to Mr. Nagle. Also, the sign needs to be changed . I went to a web site called Rip-off Reports. Out of 425 complaints on tire companies that also do mechanical work, Tires Plus was # 1 with 91 complaints with is 21%. Of these 91 complaints, 42% were for services or parts that were not needed . (yes, I read them all).

This location has had a different manager every few months so it seams. This manager is not starting out well. I can't blame him for not checking everyones work, but charging me expressly for me doing my own work ($90.00 not necessary, but on his recommendation.) is inexcusable.

The tech should be fired. One of my sons is an ASE Master Tech so I know the game. I am 78 years old and probably look like an easy mark. But as a mechanic, a machinist, engineer and General Mgr. of a machine shop, I am the wrong person to try to con on mechanical repairs.

As I was leaving, a man who appreaed to be "low man on the totum pole ", told me" I found a nail in one of your tires and fixed it at no charge". Now that is customer relations !! He will probabloy be fired for not charging the usual $25.00, but if he is, I will know about it and stir the pot again.

Across the street, Kauffman Tires fixes flats for free. When I receive my credit card, I will cut it up as I will never return. I only used it to get the discount. You have not only lost a 5 year customer with two vehicles, but also my brother-in-law who has been doing business with that store since it opened. He has three vehicles and was told that he needed spark plugs for a tune-up on his diesel truck !!!!!!

Bad management starts at the top!!! All because you tried to rip me off for a couple of hundred dollars. Should my claim be contested, I will be glad to supply a copy of the original estimate and I still have the original tir-rod end.


Copies are be sent to the following :

Derek Nagle
Rip-off report
Tires Plus consumer affairs office
Bridgestone Investors Relations
Better Business Bureau (Gwinnett County)
Duluth Chamber of Commerce
Clark Howard

Upshur
Duluth, Georgia
U.S.A.

Click here to read other Rip Off Reports on Tires Plus