Lear Capital Inc. Lear Capital Physically LOST track of my $50K precious metals and blames their shipping department Los Angeles, California
On 5-14-10, I bought over $50K worth of gold and silver, including coins, from Lear Capital. I submitted all forms to Lears agent, Tom Francini, and clarified that I did NOT want to have the metals shipped to me but that the Delaware Depository could hold my metals. Lear's agent called my cell appx. 6-9-10. I was on a trip and would not be back home until June 25. Tom stated there had been a snafu and that he thought the gold coins "may have been accidentally mailed to me", not the depository. I clarified that Tom would need to resolve the situation, as I would neither be home to receive the coins, nor to return them. Tom responded that he was certain the gold/silver would be returned to him, as I would not be present to sign for the delivery. Then, Mr. Francini NEVER CHECKED to see what hapened to the metals.
Once I returned home, I picked-up my mail at the Post Office and received two buckets of what I thought was deck paint I had ordered from L.A. Later, my painters discovered the "paint" I had left outside for 3 weeks waiting for two consecutive sunny days, was really two plastic buckets containing canvas bags of precious metals from Lear! Tom had NOT followed-up by tracking the delivery once he learned that I was out of town, nor had he asked his shippers to follow-up. He had essentially forgotten the entire matter. Afterall, it was only $50K moved in and out of my garage and all around the pool area as it was mistaken for deck paint!!! His response once I discussed this was to blame his shipping department. He takes no responsibility for not following-up on what he identified on the phone in early June as their "snafu"!
Resolution Sought: Lear needs to follow-up on every shipment and each transaction to ensure their security, so that noone else has to wonder what happened to their precious metals investment. When a shipment is assigned to go to the depository, as mine was, AND Tom sends an e-mail to the buyer, as he did to me on 5-17-10 saying the metals HAD BEEN already sent to the depository, DON't send the metals 3 weeks later and then mis-ship them. And if they are misshipped, track the metals down like a bird dog and beg the forgiveness of your originally trusting new customer! In this case Mr. Francini continues to blame the shipping department, while not even checking with them once I shipped the precious metals BACK to him, to see if they had been received. He pretends this was an odd, unusual instance, but I see from various other reports that many a "snafu" surrounds Mr. Francini, who knows well how to get your money but has no idea of how to secure it!!!!!!
Set The Record Straight
United States of America#2REBUTTAL Individual responds
Thu, June 30, 2011
I handled the transaction discussed in the referenced
complaint. While I can certainly sympathize that the client in this situation might
have an issue with the shipment of her purchase, I hardly believe that it
qualifies as a rip off . Sometimes people make mistakes and sometimes those mistakes get compounded by further mistakes. In this case there are plenty of them to go around.
Ms. Robinson ordered gold and silver which was suppose to be delivered to the Delaware
Depository as she states. The first mistake occurred when our shipping
department inadvertently shipped the Silver to her home address. The gold was
sent to the Delaware Depository.
I immediately contacted our shipping department to report the problem. My next call was to Ms. Robinson to notify her of the error. At that time I repeated what I was told by our Shipping
Manager. I told her that her silver shipment would be returned to us as it was shipped by Registered Insured Mail and the post office is required to return all unclaimed shipments made by us
after 5 business days.
This is where mistake number two occurred. Ms. Robinson
apparently had her mail placed on vacation hold. The post office just stored
her silver shipment along with the rest of her mail and didnt return the
packages as they were instructed. Since the packages were not returned, our
shipping department assumed that they were delivered.
Ms. Robinson accuses me of not following up on her shipment. It
is true that I did not follow up on her shipment as I assumed that the material
was rightfully returned by the post office and redirected to the Delaware
Depository. Once the shipment was made I am not authorized to make any changes
or redirection of shipments. I can only request changes or follow up from our
shipping department. This is for the clients protection.
Mr. Robinson reports that when she went to claim her mail she was handed two buckets of what
she thought was pool paint.
Mistake number three. The containers are clearly marked as being from Lear Capital and are substantially heaver than pool paint. She had to sign a delivery
receipt from the post office that clearly states that the packages are from
Lear Capital.
Apparently, according to this report and her conversation with me,
she moved the containers in and out of her garage without noticing that it was
not pool paint. Once she discovered she had silver instead of pool paint in her
possession she contacted me and we arranged to have the silver returned and
redirected to the depository.
Ms. Robinson makes it appear in this statement as if I did not express any remorse or offer any apology for the shipping error and the subsequent events. This is not the case at all. I was very apologetic and I took full responsibility for the error. Apparently the apology was not
enough for Ms. Robinson (her post says I should have begged for forgiveness) as
she continued to question my competence and then decided to post this slanted
version of the events on this website.
I take my responsibilities very seriously and I am responsive to all of my
clients. It should be noted that Ms. Robinson was referred to me by her father
who continues to be my client and has done at least two other transactions
since this event.
Cecil Memory
United States of America#3Consumer Comment
Sat, February 26, 2011
I have dealt with Lear. My problem with them came after I referred 4 different people to buy from them. They say if you refer one person you get a 1/0 oz gold coin. 2 people = 1/4th oz gold. 3 = 1/2 oz gold. 4 = 1oz gold coin.
On the day the the 4th person was confirmed they called me to say they no longer offer this program. Funny how they waited to receive money from the 4 referrals and when I couldn't refer anymore or go to a higher level they say it ended so they don't have to make good on their promise.
myloveisbald
Moreno Valley,#4Consumer Suggestion
Wed, December 08, 2010
I am neither a consumer of this particular product or an Employee of Lear Capital. I just would like to point out some two cents. I was with you on all your story until you said your gold 'melted like paint'. Do you realize it takes thousands of degrees in Fahrenheits to even melt gold. Far hotter than a few sunny days outside in the sun.