;
  • Report:  #1211383

Complaint Review: Phyllis Stuart - Los Angeles California

Reported By:
El Monte Filmworks - El Monte, California,
Submitted:
Updated:

Phyllis Stuart
Los Angeles, California, USA
Web:
N/A
Categories:
Tell us has your experience with this business or person been good? What's this?
Report Attachments


Phyllis Stuart owns and operates several production entities (The WIN Awards, Elephant Daze, Enthuse TV). In December 2014 Phyllis Stuart contracted me to supply and operate my jib (camera crane) and camera equipment for her "WIN Awards" event, with the promise of payment of $1000 after 20 days.


 


As the date of promised payment drew near I sent an email saying hello and checking in... no response.  More emails were sent, all professional and polite, without reply.  I tried calling her, leaving messages... no reply. The only method of communication that garnered any response was via text, and her replies were sporadic and unclear.  What was becoming clear, however, was that she was, at best, dragging her feet in paying my invoice. At the six week mark she sent me a check for $150 with a hand written letter stating that this was all she was going to pay because "her charity was out of money and was no longer functioning". (Since I subscribe to her feeds on social media and see current posts from her "defunct charity", I know this not to be true.) I returned the check to her, making it (politely) clear that I could not accept it, as it might later be construed as my acceptance of less than complete payment for my services. I did attempt to work with her and offered a one time deal: pay me half the invoice ($500) and I would let the rest go.  No response. Continued calls, texts, and emails have garnered no response from her. 


 


After two and a half months I have to conclude that Phyllis Stuart will not pay me what I am owed without legal action. I am forced to use this forum to warn others in the film and entertainment industry that Phyllis Stuart has proven untrustworthy and has not held up her end of a contract. She is currently in pre-production of a documentary film called "Elephant Daze"... I worry that she will also make false promises and agreements with cast and crew for that project as she did with me on the 2014 WIN Awards. Be aware that, from my experience, Phyllis Stuart may not be trustworthy and may rip you off.


 


http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0835831/?ref_=fn_al_nm_1


 


https://www.facebook.com/TheWINAwardsShow


 


http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3859352/




5 Updates & Rebuttals

Smileandsing

Los Angeles ,
California,
USA
Win Awards(Phyllis Stuart) Not What It Claims

#2UPDATE EX-employee responds

Wed, December 30, 2015

I am distressed to learn that Phyllis Stewart is doing another WIN awards. I was paid the first year i worked. But I personally witnessed her bully and belittle her staff (who are primarily young women) accuse people, without evidence, of stealing, be rude, mean and refused to pay several other people. I tried many times to communicate with her both verbally and by email about her behavior and that it was contrary to the message she is sending with her event. She ignored attempts by all of her staff to communicate with her. I told Ms Stewart I would never work with her again and left it at that. When I watch hard working, young women and some men give their all to a women who not only is thankless for their work but belittles, accuses and than doest pay them yet she finds money to put the event up again, my sense of justice and concern for the innocent staff this year is understandably enraged. Even the venue had trouble with and witnessed Ms Stewart's behavior. I just can not, in good conscience, hold my tongue after what I witnessed the last two years at The WIN awards. By the way, The WIN awards are just Ms Stewart's creation. There is nothing the organization does through out the year to help women. There is no staff, no classes or out reach programs etc. She hires young women off Craig's list every year, treats them in a deplorable manner, doesn't pay some of them or only partially pays them, then lives the rest of the year off what she raised for the awards show.


Phyllis Stuart Makes Good

#3Author of original report

Tue, December 22, 2015

I would like to update you regarding a previous post regarding Phyllis Stuart, President of the Women's Image network. In December 2014, Ms. Stuart contracted me to operate my camera and jib arm to help videotape the Women's Image Awards Show for a mutually agreed upon sum of money. However, after completion of the event, we came into a disgreement over payment of my invoice (retrosperctively due to possible misunderstanding regarding a call to the Beverly Hills Fire Department regarding a potential safety concern.) However, I am happy to say that as of December 21,

Phyllis Stuarts has paid my my invoice in fulland she and I have agreed to move forward in mutual respect and professional regard, and no legal action regasrding this issue will be acted upon by either party. In return for payment of my invoice, I will no llonger be contacting WIN vendors, staff, crew, clients, associates, talent, nominees, honorees, co-chairs, or any one else currently or formerly working or associated with WIN regarding this matter.I believe Ms. Stuart is a good person with a demonstared passion and laudable causes, and I wish her all the best in her future endeavors.


Stageworks

Los Angeles,
California,
USA
Additional workers abused and not paid.

#4UPDATE EX-employee responds

Fri, December 11, 2015

I was hired to work the WIN Awards she hosted 2013 at the Santa Monica Women's Club; and she did not behave in a professional way. -The majority of her staff and vendors were not paid the wages she promised, and she refused to reimburse people for out-of-pocket purchases made at her behest. -The credit cards used to make purchases for the entire event were declined repeatedly, causing delays and out-of-pocket spending by her staff -Freelance vendors including a Graphic artist/Photographer, Stylist, and Fine Artist were not paid for services rendered -She refused to pay contracted event staff including her Stage Manager and technicians. -Despite having food catered, she did not hire any catering staff, instead forcing her interns to serve food and drinks and clean the venue following load-out. -Presenters were made promises of payment/gifts that were never received -She was verbally abusive and unprofessional.


Sad but true...

#5Author of original report

Tue, March 10, 2015

It is true that I did call the Beverly Hills Fire Department and requested a Fire Marshal come to the venue after I observed Phyllis Stuart crowding tables and chairs up against fire exits, creating a potentially dangerous work environment. The room was simply too small to safety accommodate all of the tables she was trying to place. Since she was personally over-seeing the placement of the tables and chairs, it would have been a waste of time to ask her to clear the exits. When the Fire Marshal came in he made Phyllis strike at least two tables and move others to clear the Fire exits. This can all be verified by the Beverly Hills Fire Department. I take the safety of my work environment seriously.

I call Phyllis Stuart once or twice a day, to politely remind her that she owes me my rate for her show, no matter what transpired with the potential fire hazard she had created. I should also state that she had refused to pay me long before learning that I was the crew member who requested the Fire Marshal. 

 

Additionally, after my initial RipOff Report was filed, I was contacted by another crew member from one of Phyllis Stuart's previous events, stating that he had also been ripped off by her and was in the process of collecting on a judgement.


truthishere2015

beverly hills,
California,
USA
The Truth About This Report

#6REBUTTAL Individual responds

Tue, March 10, 2015

If a producer hires a one day freelancer...a cameraman, like this tool. They would not expect him to call the fire department which arrived as our event guests were arriving. No, a producer would expect a person on the team to address their concerns about a potential fire hazard (the fire deparment found NO hazard and did not fine the venue), that the day player would ask the showrunner a question. 

 I should sue this idiot. He thought he was a big man and called the government (which cost me over $700 in the end, because fire departments charge you for this thing). It also cost me overtime for the 15 other staffers, enormous confusion for the arriving guests, late start time and very late end time..which cost me in venue overtime and valet overtime.

 So the truth is that he got partial payment. I should not have paid him anything...he ruined my show / event which took be 5 months to create for a one night three hour event...

 I've been polite. But now I am out of patience. This man is nuts. He uses dozens of phone numbers and he calls me on my cell phone...at 4 AM, 2 AM, every single day. This person is a liability to any show, and all producers considering hiring this cameraman must know he is not right n the head.

 

Be WARNED...Do NOT hire Joseph Walsh...

Reports & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
Also a victim?
Repair Your Reputation!
//