;
  • Report:  #363663

Complaint Review: Bill Penney Toyota - Huntsville Alabama

Reported By:
- Huntsville, Alabama,
Submitted:
Updated:

Bill Penney Toyota
4808 University Dr Nw Huntsville, 35806 Alabama, U.S.A.
Phone:
256-562-0192
Web:
N/A
Categories:
Tell us has your experience with this business or person been good? What's this?
I had my check engine, VSC TRAC, and traction lights all come on in my 2005 Toyota SR5 one day, so I thought, okay, I will take it to the dealership to get it checked out. My fiance (the former mechanic) warned me not to be "taken in" by these people, and just to have them figure out what was wrong with it.

I take it in 10 minutes prior to open time on a Saturday and am met by Carrie, who takes note of the lights that are on and tells me it will be about two hours to test it (I was the 8th car in line-these folks aren't hurting for business), with a minimum charge of $55.00. I thought it was high, but thought, okay, at least they can tell me what the problem is.

Two hours roll by and Carrie approaches me with lots of figures scribbled down on her piece of paper, and tells me it will be a while longer, they have the error codes but it will cost $210.00 to do further testing because they still don't know exactly what the problem is. The other figures listed on the sheet are $586.00, 296.00, etc. I feel myself getting a little shocked, because my father has been in the automotive business (body work) for 35 years and I'm not used to getting shafted or connived by shady dealership people. I ask for a moment to call my fiance who confirms my suspicions and says, "get out of there now, but ask for the codes."

Carrie then informs me it will be a half hour so that my car can cool down before the wires can be removed. I go outside for the half hour and women's lib all over the place to my fiance because how dare they assume that b/c I'm a woman I'm not going to have a d**n idea about cars, error codes and how that all works.

THE FUN PART: Carrie brings me my invoice, I have no choice but to pay the $55.00 for two codes (which incidentally I am able to identify exactly what the problem was via the web later) and then drops this bomb. My catalytic converter needs to be replaced UNDER WARRANTY and they have already ordered the part. Then she has the gall to tell me that she's "real concerned" about the one code and that I need to get it fixed ASAP.

Guess what? I get the part replaced four days later and all the lights are gone. My $55.00? Also gone. Apparently they thought my intelligence was gone as well. I'd enjoy it if I got my money back, but was informed that's just too bad.

I'm a girl, not an idiot!

Huntsville, Alabama

U.S.A.


12 Updates & Rebuttals

Nuri

Washington, DC,
District of Columbia,
U.S.A.
so what if yo are a woman?

#2Consumer Comment

Wed, December 10, 2008

I didnt respond in a while, but this one I have to. Arent you tired of reading reports which start as; desabled woman, 87 young man, single mother of 1, 2 or so...thats got nothing to relate to your problem/complain. Just b/c you are anything of above, it doesnt mean you should be treated any better. As for this post...you've got it cheap and still you complain. You drove your car to the dealer for diagnosis. They told you upfront it will cost $55.00. Your boyfriend wanted codes, so he can try to repair himself ( just knowing the code WON'T mean he will know what to replace...i.e P0171), but some codes require much more tesitng since several areas can couse the same code. You have paid $55. just for 2 codes.....you have had 2 codes, one in each system, engine and traction control. In the shop where I work (Potomak, MD) it cost $129.00 per system, just to let you know the code( I know its a ripp of for you, but our customers live in $11 MILLION homes and I pay $1800.00 a month for 1 bedroom apartment).... What is your intelligence in this story? 4 days later part was replaced and the lights were gone??? How did your boyfriend lead to what parts to replace? Codes? YES. Why would the dealer scan them for free? You even declined to replace cat. convertor which was under warranty? Come on now.... Honestly, I jump in front of female customer offering my help, explain in details everything, show her around, explain how troubled system works....why? B/C if she leaves the shop happy, and I fix her car right away, she will recommend 10 other customers to look for me. BUT, if you start sh..t me with the story how your boyfriend, husband, daddy, cousin...a car tech.....WHY ARE YOU IN MY SHOP THEN? PS; Cheking auto shop in AAA listings...thats a rip off. AAA charges shops, just like BBB monthly about $800.00, and just b/c the shop is listed in AAA approved listing, doesnt mean anything. Think about it.


Paul

Ellensburg,
Washington,
U.S.A.
Tis Tis Tis

#3Consumer Comment

Mon, November 24, 2008

People may want to read before they make comments. They should Re-Read the complaint, they will see that in the third paragraph, the 16th word states "her". I could be wrong but I think this means female. And why, being a female rep, for any company, means another female won't be ripped off? Men do it all the time to each other.


Twister

Huntsville,
Alabama,
U.S.A.
Next time go to Auto Zone

#4Consumer Suggestion

Wed, October 01, 2008

Next time you have a problem like that just take it to Auto Zone. They'll read and give you the codes for free.


Twister

Huntsville,
Alabama,
U.S.A.
Next time go to Auto Zone

#5Consumer Suggestion

Wed, October 01, 2008

Next time you have a problem like that just take it to Auto Zone. They'll read and give you the codes for free.


Twister

Huntsville,
Alabama,
U.S.A.
Next time go to Auto Zone

#6Consumer Suggestion

Wed, October 01, 2008

Next time you have a problem like that just take it to Auto Zone. They'll read and give you the codes for free.


Twister

Huntsville,
Alabama,
U.S.A.
Next time go to Auto Zone

#7Consumer Suggestion

Wed, October 01, 2008

Next time you have a problem like that just take it to Auto Zone. They'll read and give you the codes for free.


Karl

Highlands Ranch,
Colorado,
U.S.A.
MASSIVE 'HANKY PANKY' is taking place!! You must...

#8Consumer Comment

Wed, September 03, 2008

NOW 'Google' the following in order to pull-up the 3 POEMS at Ripoff Report. Here is what you must now 'Google'- BERNANKE HE INHERITED A BIG PROBLEM WAS IT DUE TO ANY HANKY PANKY. If that doesn't pull up the Ripoff Report with 'FED POEM', then 'Google' this- RIP OFF REPORT TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION USA MANIPULATION, and go to the 'Updates' section!! More poems coming soon! 'THIRD QUARTER POEM' is available at the BusinessWeek Article entitled- A CREDIT CARD YOU WANT TO TOSS. (you can 'Google' it!) Thanky-you. Here's a line from 'THIRD QUARTER POEM'- This poem is over Time to make some spaghetti I'll listen to Andrea Bocelli Then I'll put on some Petty! End. 'And I won't...back...down!' - Tom Petty


Karl

Highlands Ranch,
Colorado,
U.S.A.
HANKY-PANKY!! WOMEN MUST BE EXTRA CAREFUL AT TOYOTA DEALERS BECAUSE....

#9Consumer Comment

Wed, August 27, 2008

WOMEN ARE TOYOTA'S NEW TARGET, according to a Rep who worked at a Toyota Dealership in Arizona a few years ago!! Also, Toyota Corporation will TARGET women!! 'Google' this for proof- SEXUAL HARASSMENT TOYOTA, and read the Lawsuit filed by a former Toyota executive assistant in Toyota's New York corporate offices! It seems as though 'HANKY PANKY' is on the minds of many!!!! 'Google' this- HANKY PANKY BERNANKE RIPOFF, and go to the 'Toyota Ripoff Report' and read 'FED POEM' that is one of the 'Updates'. There are two more poems for your reading enjoyment also!!! Coming soon- 'HANKY PANKY SONG' Here's a few lines- Please sing to the tune of; 'The Hokey Pokey' You put your left foot in, you pull your left foot out, you put your left foot in, and you shake it all about...you read some 'HANKY PANKY' then you turn yourself around, that's what it's all about!!!


Steven

Jacksonville,
Florida,
U.S.A.
Warranty work -- What's the problem

#10Consumer Suggestion

Sat, August 23, 2008

If they are replacing it under warranty part of that would be free maybe even all of it. What's the issue??? Did you ask if the other code could be resolved after the warranty work??? Just because the work being done may show a charge does not mean that they will pass all or any of those charges to you. That reflects costs back to the company for them to repair the vehicle (for the bean counters in the office). I am sure that if you would have gotten a rental vehicle that would have been free as well.


Andromeda

Near Roswell,
New Mexico,
U.S.A.
Peter! You just blew your credibility again.

#11Consumer Comment

Thu, August 21, 2008

Peter, 'If you are so smart then why don't you fix your vehicle yourself rather than asking Toyota for help? Apparently you know soooo much more than they do.' Space filler. Not needed. 'As for your comments about being 'ripped off' because you were female ... weren't you waited on by a female service tech?' Where did you come up with that? I can't find where the Author said Carrie was a service tech, but I could be wrong. Who changed the Authors gender? 'Why would a woman try to take advantage of another woman? Your story is greatly lacking in credibility.' The Authors credibility is fine. You just blew your own credibility because you do not know whether the service tech was/is female or not.


Friendly Help

Anderson,
South Carolina,
U.S.A.
I would wonder why your cat converter was bad.

#12Consumer Comment

Sun, August 17, 2008

My 1991 Camry went 330,000 miles and only (at the very end) needed one alternator, one starter, & one water pump. The original cat converter was still fine, as were the shocks and everything else. I can image a clogged cat causing many codes & problems except I wonder why the VSC got involved in it. At least the cat is under warranty. Maybe your friends at Bill Penney Toyota prefer the shotgun approach. You could always start looking around (now) for a respected independent shop. Check the AAA and also the 'mechanic's files' at the cartalk site.


Peter

Pony,
Alabama,
U.S.A.
If you are so smart ...

#13Consumer Comment

Sun, August 17, 2008

If you are so smart then why don't you fix your vehicle yourself rather than asking Toyota for help? Apparently you know soooo much more than they do. As for your comments about being "ripped off" because you were female ... weren't you waited on by a female service tech? Why would a woman try to take advantage of another woman? Your story is greatly lacking in credibility.

Reports & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
Also a victim?
Repair Your Reputation!
//