Eric
Perry Hall,#2Author of original report
Fri, April 13, 2007
I would disacree.so let's beat the dead horse. the product was advertized as an HK product "HK" is a trade mark , brand name period. the ad's wording" HK collapsible stock ,complete." and at $ 400.00 for a gen 1, 2 ..would be resonable . now i was accused of reading into, or assuming. if you use a TRADE or BRAND name you're stating is is that brand . if you are using TRADE or BRAND name to dicribe the item , you would word it: style, like ,for a few examples of brand name recognition in the world of firearms ' Novac sights- Lapua brass-Choate stocks-Remington primers - Nosler bullets- Ziess optics... We could play a game naming brand names and you might know the product.. Pachmayr, Swarovski, Hornady, Sig , these are all common trade names .When consumers read them,they know what to expect .\, good and bad.. companies have built reputations on these names . When discribing these you may,but do not have to use orignal or athentic or "genuine". They are what they are by TRADE MARK" i could buy a B-Square mount for an HK rifle .. it's still a B-Square , I can buy a Choate stock for my rifle , made under HK licence .. mount it on the rifle ,but still it's not HK ,it simply was not manufactured by HK . it's a Choate stock in fact many gun guys through around Trade Names to see how knowlegable a buddy may be. - and this is not just with firearms. other examples ; you can put an Elderbrock manafold on a Chevy ,Ford, etc ..but is not a chevy or ford part..is still a Elderbrock and what sets on top of that maybe a Holly . Bosch ignition- , Hella lights, Brembo..etc these are all after mark parts , distinguihsed by brand name . last example ; swiss army knife's ..alot of fraud in the selling of these.. i can sell you a multi-tool knife , that looks like a swiss army knife , we all know what they look like . It may be a swiss army knife made by X company ..and i could advertise it as a Swiss Army Knife, and let's call it an Officer Swisse just to throw the kiddies off.. and just to drive it home let's also write GENUINE swiss army knife , and legally by definition it is a genuine X brand swiss army knife. BUT, when I advertise the above knife as an " VICTORINOX swiss army knife, Officer Swisse mod" or a "WENGER" swiss army knife it better be just that. BECAUSE , and this is the point - VICTORINOX LIKE HK, IS A TRADE NAME . and the product may be a GENUINE X BRAND . but is NOT ,nor will ever be a VICTORINOX. I know in the Firearms world , because of regulations that have hurt sales etc. Firearms manufactures have dropped certain lines and had regulated guns manufactured under licence in the US by third parties .. and even in these cases manufactures will state this. FYI. not applicable in this case but could add to the confusion. all this aside - I agree with your second point IF i'd seen there was no contact number .I should have ran for the hills ... i'm sorry to say I took Florida Guns Works at their word I clearly thought that HK meant HK. Semantics a side ; I looked up the word's Original , Factory, Authentic ; and the varing diffinitions .. In fact if parts were made by a third party on HK tooling to HK spec ,these parts could be diffined as AUTHENTIC:' websters- "conforming to an original so as to reproduce essential features" FACTORY:- anything decribed as factory "slang" built by,.. non discribtive. ORIGINAL: -Many definitions, "First, inventive "that of which copies , reproductions or translations are made .a work comprised of first hand ." again all these definitions, are general in reference and can be manipulated . GENUINE - is the discribition I might have been looking for , webster's" actually produced by the alleged source."....or is it? even this definition could be used to mislead - knowing what i know now and have read. POSIBLITIES > a third world manufacturer name the company Happy Kamper. "Hk" invert the colors of the logo,hell you don't even need a logo... make the parts for pennies on the dollar and sell them close to the Heckler& Koch pricing an advertise as GENUINE HK PARTS . legal yes, Moral certainly not. I just wasted time writing a describition of who struck John and how hard and the semantics there in.. there should be something to cut through all the crap, a proper way to assure identifaction there is and it's THE TRADE MARK . the reason why reputable manufacturers/companies world wide spend time & money on Logo's ,Patentends ,and registering Trade mark's .. what's the use of having them ,other than trying to avoid a long expaination every time you want to buy something. it's to assure that a IBM is IBM . SONY is SONY , and yep HK is HK . thank you for your feed back .
Carl
Postal,#3Consumer Suggestion
Fri, April 13, 2007
Eric. I hold a valid FFL and have done business over he internet since 1995. While I have never done business with Florida Gun works or any other alias they might use, I have to tell you that I think that you are wrong here. When spending I always call to talk to a live person and have my questions answered. While symantically it might have been better for you if the ad said 'FOR USE WITH' or 'NOT GENUINE HK', what they did write was clear to me on the first reading. You obviously knew the value of the genuine article, yet felt that the product offered was the genuine thing at a massively discounted price. A simple solution would have been to pick up the phone and call to make sure. The problem here is one of assumption on your part. No where does it even imply this is a genuine HK part. I do think that 20% restocking is rather high. Eric, try to bargin for either a 100% store credit(that is if there is anything else you might want) or a 100% refund.