;
  • Report:  #112952

Complaint Review: Hotel.com - Cityclub - Manhatten New York

Reported By:
- slc, Utah,
Submitted:
Updated:

Hotel.com - Cityclub
44 Street Manhatten Manhatten, New York, U.S.A.
Web:
N/A
Categories:
Tell us has your experience with this business or person been good? What's this?
i booked and paid for a room 2 weeks in advance with hotel.com only to arrive and find out that i had no room. I flew 7 hours to manhatten and paid $40 in cab fares to get to the hotel and then had to go to jersy city to finally find a room. Hotel.com never notified me that the hotel was booked although they said that they did, I was stranded and had already paid over $500 for the room- they told me on the phone that it would take 2 weeks for a refund of my money. So there I was in NY with no hotel and no money.

Very poor service- they took my money and are holding it for 2 weeks on false pretence that I would get a room.

I wonder how much money they make in interest off of ripping all of these people offlike this.

$#^&(^$ they ruined my trip!

Kurt

slc, Utah
U.S.A.


5 Updates & Rebuttals

Tim

Valparaiso,
Indiana,
U.S.A.
In reponse to Kasey, this is what I have found in dealing with third party reservation websites

#2Consumer Comment

Tue, October 19, 2004

1) You need to shop around, and part of that shopping around should DEFINITELY include calling the hotel directly. To ease your search for the lowest rate, there is a program (free download) called "Travelaxe." Travelaxe will search a slew of hotels in a given city, and list the prices from multiple websites, usually including the hotel's own website. 2) Check Hotwire and Priceline. Most times they will find you the lowest rates. The only problem with these guys is that you don't know wxactly which hotel you will be staying at until you pay for it, but you will know the star rating, amenities, and location. 3) If the hotel's rate is lower, the same, or not much higher than what you have found elsewhere, go with the hotel. Otherwise, go with the best deal you've found. 4) In my experience, things are just as likely to go wrong whether you deal with the hotel directly or with a third party. Hotels will give a reserved room away regardless of whether the room was reserved through them or an outside source. Hotel websites are just as likely to be misleading as other sites. The only real benefit of going through the hotel directly, based on my personal experiences, is that it's easier to deal with one party insetad of two. If your reservation gets loused up and you made it directly with the hotel, it is usually much easier to resolve than if you went through a third party. This is why you have to perform a sort of risk-benefit analysis. If you find a substantially cheaper rate on an outside website, go ahead and take it, but realize that the risks involved are greater. Just make sure you go through a reputable site, and not something that you've never heard of before.


Cory

San Antonio,
Texas,
U.S.A.
Different Experiences

#3Consumer Comment

Sun, October 17, 2004

People have different experiences. If I had yours I'd be really mad too. I used hotel.com for our trip out to NM and was totally satisfied with their service. I got printouts from them of all the prices, and room reservations, including confirmation numbers. I first checked with the hotels themselves on the web, and by phone, and in most cases, but not all, HC was less expensive. At La Quinta, per night, HC was about $30 cheaper. Some of the clerks weren't too happy with the discounts. Did you receive a room confirmation number? If the hotel over booked, and gave away your room, that's not HC's fault. I also called the hotels to verify my reservations the day before. I didn't want to get stuck out in the middle of no place without a room.


Cory

San Antonio,
Texas,
U.S.A.
Different Experiences

#4Consumer Comment

Sun, October 17, 2004

People have different experiences. If I had yours I'd be really mad too. I used hotel.com for our trip out to NM and was totally satisfied with their service. I got printouts from them of all the prices, and room reservations, including confirmation numbers. I first checked with the hotels themselves on the web, and by phone, and in most cases, but not all, HC was less expensive. At La Quinta, per night, HC was about $30 cheaper. Some of the clerks weren't too happy with the discounts. Did you receive a room confirmation number? If the hotel over booked, and gave away your room, that's not HC's fault. I also called the hotels to verify my reservations the day before. I didn't want to get stuck out in the middle of no place without a room.


Cory

San Antonio,
Texas,
U.S.A.
Different Experiences

#5Consumer Comment

Sun, October 17, 2004

People have different experiences. If I had yours I'd be really mad too. I used hotel.com for our trip out to NM and was totally satisfied with their service. I got printouts from them of all the prices, and room reservations, including confirmation numbers. I first checked with the hotels themselves on the web, and by phone, and in most cases, but not all, HC was less expensive. At La Quinta, per night, HC was about $30 cheaper. Some of the clerks weren't too happy with the discounts. Did you receive a room confirmation number? If the hotel over booked, and gave away your room, that's not HC's fault. I also called the hotels to verify my reservations the day before. I didn't want to get stuck out in the middle of no place without a room.


Kasey

New Haven,
Connecticut,
U.S.A.
websites

#6Consumer Comment

Sat, October 16, 2004

they make about 20% off you! my suggestion is to book directly with your hotel of choice. do not book through websites! you can get a cheaper rate directly with the hotel or atleast be sure you have a room! certain websites raise the rate that the hotel is offering so your actually paying more! read some of my previous posts about these 3rd party websites and you will see the whole "deal"

Reports & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
Also a victim?
Repair Your Reputation!
//