;
  • Report:  #783141

Complaint Review: Conman Kevin Conway Conway's Vintage Treasures - Plainville Massachusetts

Reported By:
John - Westport, Connecticut, United States of America
Submitted:
Updated:

Conman Kevin Conway Conway's Vintage Treasures
152 East Bacon St Plainville, 02762 Massachusetts, United States of America
Phone:
Web:
http://www.cvtreasures.com
Categories:
Tell us has your experience with this business or person been good? What's this?
Conman Kevin Conway purchases items for a cheap price on Ebay and then makes up a false story with a COA. His user name on Ebay is just_vintage and I am in the midst of a lawsuit with him as he sells forged items.Notice how he keeps his purchases private on Ebay.That is a major warning sign of a crook.What has he got to hide?What is the goal of a forger of autographs? Basically they try to forge a signature and make their creation resemble an original. Some forgers are not happy with trying to duplicate a simple signature on a souvenir item such as a baseball, photograph or first day cover. Many of these forgeries eventually get Certificates of Authenticity from the companies who claim they authenticate autographs. One of the reasons for this, you simply have to look at who is doing the authenticating. Many of the names are not recognizable. Autograph authenticating has become a big business and its all about money!

The autograph market is flooded with forged autographs with COAs stating they are genuine.

This recent phenomenon of non genuine autographs being accompanied with COAs stating the item is genuine is now an epidemic and Conway's Store is a leader of this trend.

Some forgers get very greedy and are not happy making a few hundred dollars for one of their creations. Usually the greedier they get the sloppier they get. For example, Kevin Conway decided he wanted to create a treasure that would sell for over $100,000. Instead of using his creative mind, Conway went to Charles Hamiltons book American Signatures, Volume one and chose to duplicate, word for word, including corrections, a John Hancock letter. A fabulous content letter stating: I do certify that John Paul Jones was duly commissioned and appointed to command the armed Sloop called the Providence and that this Sloop is now employed in the service of the thirteen United States of North America witness my hand October 29th 1776 John Hancock.

Such a high profile item, illustrated in a major autograph reference book was able to make it into our market because of a few unconscious persons in this industry. Conway's Vintage Treasures actually sold this item to me in excess of $100,000.

I decided to put the item up for sale.

This very high end item was easily identified as a forgery by many professionals when the collector decided to offer this item for sale. Some of the dealers and auction houses who identified this as a forgery was Joe Maddalena and Brian Chanes of Profiles in History, Paul Richards, Superior Galleries, Ira & Larry Goldberg Coins & Collectibles, The History Buff and a few others.

One autograph professional stated: Dont know how this letter got this far, anyone doing the slightest bit of research could see this was copied out of Charles Hamiltons book!

So now you know my story.Conway refuses to refund my money and I am pressing charges with the State Attorney General along with the civil suit.


26 Updates & Rebuttals

Kevin Conway

United States of America
Author of this Report VERY DISTURBED

#2UPDATE Employee

Wed, January 18, 2012

 I am the President of CV Treasures.  I have been collecting and selling Genuine Historical Autographed Memorabilia for over 30 years.   Not only is collecting a passion but it is also a livelihood.  So, like any highly reputable dealer that discovers a cancer within the industry that can do great harm, such as an Obvious Autograph Forger, I speak out.  IN this case, the Author of this report.   (NOTE: the Author is NOT John from Westport Connecticut.  This report author and seller of autograph forgeris from New Jersey stole this identity from an autograph forum.  More evidence of pathological behavior. ).

That is what happened about 4-5 years ago as detailed below. 

About 4-5 years ago I noticed a seller on eBay that was buying photos and then weeks later that same photo would be autographed, by deceased celebrities (JFK, Bela Lugosi, John Wayne, etc).  I commented on this fraudulent autograph seller on the autograph forum Is It real.  He was eventually banned from selling autographs by eBay . But then I noticed this same individually from New Jersey opened a website that is inundated with obvious forgeries.

Well , of course like most commen , at the time he threatened to sue me for outing him.  Such empty threats are common from those who engage in criminal activity.  Meanwhile, I didnt hear from him for the past few years.  Then in the Autograph Magazine Live forum I noticed a derogatory post by an individual that I was certain was this same guy.   At the same time I was informed by a customer that there were  several Ripoff type reports on the internet by this person stating I sold him a John Hancock for over $100,000 that I forged and would not refund him.   Well, the good thing is he didnt make much effort to make his claim sound remotely believable. You see,  I have never even owned or sold a John Hancock (I WISH I did!), and Never sold anything at a fraction of $100,000.  Way out of my league.  

* AND, of course this individual could never provide any proof of purchase or even ownership of such a document.

** If you ever read about someone claiming to have bought a Non-Genuine autograph from us, ask for a legitimate proof of purchase.  They will NOT be able to provide any.  WHY? Because it is only ONE person posting all the derogatory statements.

The same fraudulent autograph dealer mentioned above.  We have not had a reputation for being a highly reputable dealer for over 25+ years for being dishonest.    

Furthermore, if we EVER sold a FAKE autograph or not fully refund an autograph that did NOT pass JSA or PSA authentication, we would lose our flawless reputation of 25+ years, not to mention our UACC Dealer designation.    Unlike sellers of autograph forgeries we are NOT afraid to guarantee JSA or PSA authentication.   Those in the business of forgeries tend to ridicule
independent authentication services since the last thing they want is an "independent" analysis of their fake autographs.   These
same unscrupulous individuals also often quote the anti-3rd party authentication blogs.

Yu can read the article we wrote on this experience along with what the e-commerce industry calls Cyber terrorism.  Namely, unscrupulous people like the Author of this Ripoff report,  that create fabricated, malicious reports under anonymous identities for the sole purpose of TRYING to silence those who Out their criminal activity.    NOTE: the very bizarre behavior below where
he creates several shill type responses and then in between claims it is I who created them.   This behavior is consistent with someone who reports to Scamming innocent, inexperienced consumers.   Full Article is at:

http://www.cvtreasures.com/fraud-autograph-seller-attacks-us-page-44


voiceofreason

North Carolina,
United States of America
Incredi-Bull

#3Consumer Comment

Wed, November 09, 2011

The audacity of whoever keeps posting the obvious shill responses "defending" CV Treasures and Conway is so blatant and unmasked, as to make me wonder if in fact these "defenses" aren't actually being posted by a competitor to make readers THINK the company is writing its own shills.

Whatever the case, I think anyone who wastes money "collecting" such high priced nonsense is basically begging to be ripped off, no matter who the seller is.

What value can an autograph have to anyone normal unless they received it in person from the signer? How can anyone, anywhere attest 100% to the veracity of such a thing?

The losers who get ripped off trying to collect things whose true origins can rarely be authenticated are close to being on par, in my opinion, with those who go to psychics.

Hey Mambo, Mambo Italiano. Anyone got Mambo's autograph?


Paul

Ohio,
United States of America
Thanks to author

#4Consumer Comment

Wed, November 09, 2011

Thanks to author.

Because of this report, I've googling Conway's Vintage Treasures and I think that is a great website. I've looked at many sites, but this one is original and attractive. So many beautiful vintage memorabilia and I think I will buy it one for my collection.

Once again, thanks to author :). 


David

Washington DC,
United States of America
Reliable company

#5Consumer Comment

Wed, November 09, 2011

Everyone has their own experience and opinion about CV Treasures. For me, this is a reliable company and Kevin is one of great man. It is truly rare to find honest, helpful, and friendly people such as Kevin. I'm sure that he will respond your issue if you contact him.


Bobby

Colorado,
United States of America
I have purchased numerous collectibles from Conway's Vintage Treasures

#6Consumer Comment

Wed, November 09, 2011

I have purchased numerous collectibles from Conway's Vintage Treasures and been impressed
with this company.

I'm sorry author, maybe I'm a lucky customer and you're not.


Piere

Oregon,
United States of America
Please use polite words to arguing

#7General Comment

Wed, November 09, 2011

Please use polite words to arguing.

I appreciate every opinion here.

Nothing is stupid; just different opinion about CV Treasures.


Velicia

United States of America
Raise the rating of CV Treasures

#8General Comment

Wed, November 09, 2011

I think this report would likely raise the rating of CV Treasures on the Internet :p. All intelligent people will look for CV Treasures on search engine and maybe they will become their loyal customers. Who's knows? Many people are sympathetic to those who are marginalized.


Robert

Buffalo,
New York,
USA
Stupid is as stupid does...

#9Consumer Comment

Wed, November 09, 2011

** OK, I've lowered myself to our level long enough.

You certainly have!  LMAO!  I can't stop laughing!


Robert

Irvine,
California,
U.S.A.
To the owner

#10Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

You are just blowing what ever credibility you had.  If you think Robert from Buffalo is actually the OP then might I suggest that you take a look around this site to see his other postings on many different companies.

By the way why would you keep your comments private on ebay if you had nothing to hide? 


voiceofreason

North Carolina,
United States of America
Such an unimaginative obvious shill job

#11Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

Every single shill response above has the same grammatical problems. It's as obvious as a green light meaning Go and red meaning Stop. Therefore we can all now rest assured that the original report against the company is indeed based on credible ground.
I'm surprised you didn't make the same grammar mistakes forging antique letters.
I'm gonna try my hand at it for you:
I to certifying that it famous John Paul Jones to duly commissioner and appoints
it commanding armed Sloop it call Providence and what Sloop is to employed to services of thirteen Uniting States to North Americans witness my feet October 29th 1776 John Handcock.

As for the OP, how on earth did you let yourself give this guy $100,000 outside normal Ebay channels for this?


Rick

United States of America
To "Mr Shill aka Robert"

#12REBUTTAL Owner of company

Tue, November 08, 2011

"Robert" of course the NJ Forger, using ANOTHER "Fake" name , just as you did in the autograph forums and here in Ripoffreport where you STOLE someone else's identity from the autograph magazine Live forum.  

THEN WHY don't you STOP creating these , as you define, "Shill" responses, JUST so you can come in here and accuse US of creating them.    Or at least don't make it soo obvious it is YOU.

We don't need to create "fake" responses. As you can see there are PLENTY legitimate responses to your FABRICATED Malicious Report you started above, to "get even" with Kevin Conway for "outing" your forgery activity on eBay several years ago.    WHY don't you give us all your website address so we can all judge for ourselves how legitimate YOU are??

BTW, it was NOT ONLY Us who reported your forgery operation to eBay which resulted in eBay BANNING you from selling autographs for the past several years.  There were several others who reported you. 

** OK, I've lowered myself to our level long enough.  People like you eventually self-destruct. So I iwll let nature take it course, and no longer respond to your nonsense.

Hopefully one day these ripoff report websites will no longer be a safe haven for Scam-Artists to create fabricated, illegitimate , slanderous attacks on others.




Robert

Buffalo,
New York,
USA
More illiterate shills

#13Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

You really should pay your shills more.

I didn't write this Ripoff Report.  The alleged owner of the company posted a rebuttal and should have left it at that.  But no, we now see a march of illiterate shills posting here.  It isn't about "composition 101" as much as it is about 5th grade grammar.

Whenever a bunch of illiterate rebuttals pop up it always throws a cloud over the authenticity of the so called "consumer comments."


George

Michigan,
United States of America
Absolutely I trust CV Treasures

#14Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

Absolutely I trust CV Treasures. I just bought vintage movie poster through this online store a month ago. It has delivered on time and the pricing was great ;)


Beryl M.

Kentucky,
United States of America
Just share my experience

#15Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

If you were not satisfied with Conway's Vintage Treasures, please contact Kevin.

I ever got a problem on delivery but Kevin has solved it in an hour. He was a honest and friendly man and was easy to talk to him.

*Just share my experience


Deana

Oklahoma,
United States of America
100% scam report

#16Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

100% scam report :)

I have made purchased with Kevin and Conway's vintage treasures many times and he always contacts me to make sure that I'm happy with his service. All issues always fixed soon. Every complaints and questions has answered. 


Justin

Ohio,
United States of America
I always satisfied with Conway's vintage treasures service

#17Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

I always satisfied with Conway's vintage treasures service. Kevin always did correctly as his promised. I feel secure to make purchase with his company through CV treasures website every time.


Garneta

New York,
United States of America
I still believe to CV Treasures

#18Consumer Comment

Tue, November 08, 2011

I still believe to CV Treasures as a place to buy vintage items for my collection.

Hopefully your problem resolved soon.


Inspector

Tobyhanna,
Pennsylvania,
USA
You think Robert posted this?

#19Consumer Comment

Mon, November 07, 2011

You just shot down your credibility with that statement.


Jake

United States of America
To Mr "Just a Thought" (aka the original poster)

#20REBUTTAL Owner of company

Sun, November 06, 2011

Mr  Just a Thought, obviously the original poster , aka Forger.   Who by the way is NOT "John from Westport, CT". The only John from Westport, CT I know is one of the most reputable autograph dealers in the autograph industry,..  THis fraud who posted this report has been , cowardly using various names he picked up in the autograph forums. He has essentially stolen several REAL people's identity, which will be another criminal indictment when we finish our investigation.  His REAL name has been already submitted to authorities.     Two points.

1). Looking at the time stamps of the two broken English comments, I think it is obvious the original owner of this fabricated , slanderous report is in a very desperate state in life.  So, since he cannot DENY his fictitious report, he changes the subject, to English Composition 101.  NO doubt consistent with this fraudulent lifestyle.  Not to mention his obsession with Conways Vintage Treasures. 

2).  We are all still waiting for you to produce a receipt, proof of payment, ANY evidence at all you ever bought a John Hancock letter from Conway's Vintage Treasures . Surely you have a cancelled check for the over $100,000 story you concocted ??  By the way, wouldn't a John Hancock that sold for over $100,000 be a record sale that would surely be picked up by the media or at least the autograph community?   Please post images of your receipt, cancelled check to Conways Vintage Treasures.  It would be great to see this "letter"..?   NOT Holding My Breath.....;}

I think those who stop by their website at www.cvtreasures.com, can see the category of material being sold.   Many vintage treasures yes, but far from six figure items.


Jeanne

Michigan,
United States of America
Trusted source

#21Consumer Comment

Sun, November 06, 2011

I recently bought my first vintage movie poster from Kevin Conway's Vintage Treasures.

He is a trusted source and one I would turn to in expertise for vintage items.

I have no problem with him.


Joe

Texas,
United States of America
Do not need to discredit someone else

#22General Comment

Sun, November 06, 2011

We never know who's writing on the internet and I wonder who is right here. Please make deal with CV Treasures, if you need their service. If not, do not need to discredit someone else.


Robert

Buffalo,
New York,
USA
Just a thought...

#23Consumer Comment

Sat, November 05, 2011

If you're going to have SHILLS post here in an attempt to repair your "internet reputation" you should at least hire folks who can WRITE IN ENGLISH.

Tell us, are your shills in India or the Philippines?


Emma

Florida,
United States of America
No forgeries or phonies in CV Treasures

#24Consumer Comment

Sat, November 05, 2011

No forgeries or phonies in CV Treasures and I knew that.

I was very pleased with their service. All the information on their website was 100% accurate. I have proved by my self because I have bought vintage photos to them twice and they did my orders correctly.

Please try their service by yourself. I'll wonder if you're not satisfied.


Christopher

Ohio,
United States of America
I ever made a purchased with Conway's Vintage Treasures

#25Consumer Suggestion

Sat, November 05, 2011

I just leave comment here because I ever made a purchased with Conway's Vintage Treasures.

I have contacted Kevin before made purchased via e-mail. He was a honest and polite man. He has answered all my questions and explained about the products detail, payment, packaging and shipping items. I'm sure that he was a reliable seller and he might not deceive the consumer.

I suggest you to contact him if you get problems. I'm sure he will respect you and I hope this case will solve soon.

Regard,
Christopher


Christine Emily

Los Angeles,
California,
USA
I have many times make purchases to CV Treasures

#26Consumer Comment

Fri, November 04, 2011

I have many times make purchases to CV Treasures and Kevin Conway has served me well. I ever got the trouble on delivery package but he fixed it soon and I get the stuff I bought. Kevin Conway always cares to his customers. No worries to make purchases with him and his company.


Nofearman

NY,
New York,
U.S.A.
This post Written by a KNown Autograph Forger

#27REBUTTAL Owner of company

Sat, October 15, 2011

This report is 100% Fictional

The person who created this fabricated report is an autograph  forger  who  was identified and called out on an autograph forum, and this is his retaliation.   Conways has NEVER owned or sold a $100,000 treasure.   Conways has NEVER owned or sold a John Hancock letter.   The method he mentions of forging from a Hamilton book, certainly reveals the details of his own Forgery business. 

 If you would like proof this is a 100% fictional posting contact Conways Vintage Treasures and he will provide the REAL story and motives behind this persons malicious campaign.       But, when you expose criminal activity like this person, such retaliation is expected.

The guy who keeps posting these reports is doing so, under phony names.  You can actually type Conways Vintage Treasures in Google and you will find he has made multiple of this copied and pasted fabricated, slanderous posting under various names he took off the autograph forum.   The person is an autograph  forger  who  was identified and called out on an autograph forum, and this is his retaliation.   If you would like proof this is a 100% fictional posting contact Conways Vintage Treasures and he will provide the REAL story and motives behind this persons malicious campaign.       But, when you expose criminal activity like this person, such retaliation is expected.

But, the good news is when this much attention and effort is afforded by the unscrupulous elements of the autograph industry, you know they are doing something right.   So visit their website today and experience for yourself some of the most extraordinary historical autograph memorabilia that makes others so envious.    Conways Vintages Treasures  Guarantee the Authenticity of Everything we sell for Life and we have a solid 25 year reputation.    If it is not already PSA or JSA certified it is 100% Guaranteed to pass certification.  Our Guarantee goes beyond what you will find  with many other dealers, particularly the shady dealer who wrote this posting.

Reports & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
Also a victim?
Repair Your Reputation!
//