Mike r
Mendon,#2REBUTTAL Individual responds
Thu, December 02, 2010
The matter reported on is based on a commercial lease for a property leased by one Cynthia Ryan. The property is a horse farm, including barns, lounge and indoor riding arena on 30 acres of land. The lease was a net, net lease.
The problem started several months after Ryan took possession. Smith who was not a tenant and now says she was only a friend, approached my wife with totally unreasonable demands concerning the property. My wife advised Ryan that she had no problem letting her out of the lease. Ryan then begged my wife to stay and said Smith would no longer be involved.
Several years later, when Ryan vacated the property because she claimed she could no longer afford to pay the rent, my wife let her out of the lease and returned $270, plus interest of the $2500 security deposit. Ryan with Smiths help filed a law suit demanding the whole deposit be returned.
I was never party to the lease and I never sued Ryan. Smith knew it since her husband, William T. Pryor, Esq., is an attorney and reviewed the lease prior to its being signed and represented Ryan.
With Smith counseling Ryan and also appearing as a witness the matter was settled at trial with the Courts intervention and my wife paying Ryan an additional $629 out of the $2500. The case was in the City Court City of Rochester, NY, titled Cynthia A. Ryan dba Enterprise Farm, Plaintiff vs. Gail Rudin and Michael Rudin Defendants. Docket Number: 2008 SC 22923 and is public record.
On May 27, 2009, my wife and I sued libel and slander. The matter is pending in the Supreme Court of the