;
  • Report:  #264971

Complaint Review: Midfield Animal Clinic - Birmingham Alabama

Reported By:
- Birmingham, Alabama,
Submitted:
Updated:

Midfield Animal Clinic
1301 57th St. W Birmingham, Alabama, U.S.A.
Phone:
205-925-2698
Web:
N/A
Categories:
Tell us has your experience with this business or person been good? What's this?
It's hard for me to believe what i have experienced and what i have learned regarding the "healthcare" for your pets.

I own a dog who's age is around 11.5 years. Up to this point and i believe most likely this dog is still healthy. I was going to take him in winter for

a general checkup and rabies shot this winter, along with addressing toe paw nails that have grown excessively long and appears to create some discomfort while walking him, infact my understanding unless this is addressed, the likelihood of injury increases.

Anyhow, as i already stated, this dog has appeared healthy for the most part, sure it's slowed down and there's alot of graying around the nose

In the last couple of months i've noticed him skidding his paw nails on the hardwood floor and as stated did some research on the internet regarding this, which yes this can possibly result in injury.

In the last couple of days, it's been hot. While he had excess to water, he may not have drank it. Also i try not to overfeed him to keep him healthy.

However a couple of nights ago, the dog lost the ability to stand up with his hind legs and even worse his front arms kept skidding on the floor. Just the

slightest amount of dirt made it impossible to get a grip.

What i didn't realize he suffered a injury and i entrusted taking him to the vet.

The vet observed him and obviously this dog was in some pain. While i did the best i could during the examination to bring up the long nails and excessive hair growth around the paws, the vet stated this was not a issue.

I was given a diagnosis regarding the following diseases:

1) severe suffering arthritis which creates pain all over him,

2) Demyelination (equivalent to neurologic damage - severe), 3) Severe Spinal degeneration,

4) Cystitis,.

He gave him two shots which i clearly asked him the duration of those shots, which he replied 24 hours. The vet stated this dog should be put to sleep, he is not going advanced age and he will never recover from this severe degeneration, but as a last resort if we can take away this severe pain. but at best he's at end stage. His response to how long will he live. weeks/months, very hard pressed 3 - 6 months. If he needs more Rimadyl,

it's $1 day. I brought up the question of rabies shot and clearly he stated this dog is end stage, the degeneration/advanced aging is too much

------

Well that evening, he kept sliding on the hard wood floors and i kept him on a padded area. While he was asleep, i took a good solid look at his paws and the amount of hair growth on the pads, well i trimmed it back.

------

The next day, i called the vets office and told them there's a possibility of

a mis-diagnosis. When i spoke 2 sentences, which were there's that possibility and a sentence about the nails and immediately he cut me off

and stated then find another vet and immediately hung up

I very much questioned whether this was a ethics issue, not to get him

back or anything like that... just can the professionally licensed doctor

really do that and how many other people does he do that to? After

calling another ethical animal hospital, clearly there are ethics and referred

me to the AVMA or in Alabama the ALAVMA.

I then began to question the charges of $89.07, which definitely seemed

fair, that didn't seem excessive, until it became apparent later tonight i

looked at the front paws he's been skidding on and i could clearly see why

he couldn't get up. Last night the cutting back the hair on the back paws

stopped the skidding on the back paws and i can clearly understand now

why he injured himself and by cutting back the hair while he was asleep

most likely has stopped him from injuring himself. Still, the nails are

excessively long (which can result in back/spine injury) and i'm not sure

how far back to cut them.... anyhow at this age, he should have received

a accurate examination, which i'm going to need to do now again... but this

time with a ethical animal hospital.

This dog is not end stage and the only suffering appears related to injuring

himself. I'm sure there is some arthritis, but those excessive long nails

appear alot more painful to the paws, infact i have never noticed this dog

exhibiting arthritic symptoms.

Unless this is more than a minor bladder infection, this dog appears healthy

and i plan to have him examined by a competent vet... his teeth, nails,

and overall concerns at 11.5 years old.

And since i'm going to have to pay again for another vet to examine this dog,

i am very much considering contacting my credit card company and possibly

the state professional licensing/ethics.... but what's really the use of that?

It is very hard for me to believe when attempting to explain twice the concerns of the nails, which then would have brought up the issue of years

of fur growth on the paw pads, clearly the vet would have realized this dog

had a minor injury to the muscles.

The shots given yesterday have long worn off, i am not going to giving this

dog one single Rimadyl... the super premium senior dog food already has the Chrodroitin sulfate and glucosamine, which most likely is why i've really noticed any Arthritis symptoms in the past.

---------

I just hope anyone else anyone else, either at that animal hospital or anywhere else does not allow their dog to suffer in the future by such

negligence and ethical concerns. If i didn't realize the fur covering the

pads had grown so excessively, literally i had to wet the hardwood floor

to stop him from slipping/collapsing and injuring himself, i would have

subsituted Rimadyl....

But now i've learned... this dog as of tonight appears healthy, sure he's

slowed down but this clearly appears to be a tendency to injure himself,

fortunately realized in time, before some serious permanent injury did

occur. My understanding Rimadyl is short term inflamatory and to never

use it long term unless the blood work is monitored, it can damage the

liver and only when the aminal has permanent conditions (that doesn't

include long nails and fur covering the pads :)

So that's about it and my experience + what i can pass on to other pet

owners... oh and that super premium dog food or better yet making the

dog food yourself, really does extend the health, particularly feeding a

little bit less food then needed.

The best i can make of this episode was it took months to realize something

that resulted in a tendency to injure himself, when he began sliding all the

time, finally it appears he must have slightly injured the leg muscle.

All it took is cutting back the hair covering the paws and it appears all that

Arthritis, spinal, demyelination has resolved itself. Only time will tell... i'll

update this report in a few weeks, then again few months from now..

but please please to very careful regarding the animal hospital you trust

your pets to... for me, i caught the symptoms early, entrusted a professional,

and in this case he really would have suffered until what appears as a healthy dog really would have finally seriously injured himself

oh.... and just before cutting back the fur around the front paw pads, yes

i took some digital jpg photo's and i guess i took take some pictures after

the hair was cut back, the nails still are long, but that's not why the injury

was occuring. I absoluetly cannot believe a professional animal medical doctor diagnosed severe painful arthritic, severely degenerated neurological

degeneration and advanced aging to the spine when it appears as a minor

muscle injury.... as soon as the hair was cut back, the cause of the of

what was causing injury was taken the way.

As a last note, just to mention, by slipping and sliding on the floor, finally when injury occured, literally the day he just couldn't stand on his hind

legs without a tendency to collapase. The day that began, by the following

day he was to the vet. By that evening, i kept wetting the floor to prevent

him from sliding. The injection from yesterday is long gone and the muscle

pain has already healed. PS: If you have hard wood floors and your dog

slides, the dirt can cause less grip, the more fur around the pads and long

nails, eventually can result in permanently injuring the pets back/spine, in

this case, fortunately i realized in time. Even worse from this point forward

Rimadyl and finally injury so bad, i would need to put this dog to sleep. PPS:

it is hard for me to believe a vet couldn't realize this, but what is really beyond belief is his unwillingness to learn and continue to practice in this

nature, which i would estimate he's done it for years and probably will continue.

Rich

Birmingham, Alabama

U.S.A.


5 Updates & Rebuttals

Mark

Birmingham,
Alabama,
USA
Midfield Animal Clinic chew down by Rich

#2Consumer Comment

Tue, October 24, 2017

 My family and most of my relatives locally have used MAC for almost 40 years. We have gotten to know them over the years and they are absolutely some of the finest and professional group I have encountered. I'm not going to write a book but I could. I would put any animal In their trust, and have. Still do.


Tony

Calera,
Alabama,
United States of America
good experiences with this clinic

#3Consumer Comment

Mon, May 16, 2011

i have been using this clinic for over 17 years and have had only great experiences. a few years ago my 15 year old chihuahua died and the vet that had been taking care of her actually cried with us and did a wonderful job of preparing her body for burial. She was given to us and she looked as if she was just lying there sleeping. I truly believe that the vet at this clinic we use is an animal lover himself and has dedicated himself to giving the best care and health solutions possible to his clients. He has never overcharged or done anything to cause us to mistrust him.


Georgie

Bessemer,
Alabama,
USA
My experience with Midfield Animal Clinic

#4Consumer Comment

Sat, February 12, 2011

I have used Midfield Animal Clinic since the early 80's and have sent many friends there as well.

Dr. Armstrong, the owner and his fellow vet there Dr. Alley, have ALWAYS been very professional and very kind to me and my animals. Like anyone else , they could have made a mistake in diagnosis, though I myself have never had this problem with them. That would be the reason they would have recommended a second opinion to the man who registered the complaint.

I have always found that they have listened to me about what the problems with my pets were, and find it really hard to believe that this man was totally disregarded. That is NOT the Dr.'s I know there. I wonder if the man got his second opinion, and what the diagnoses was. It would seem if he did and it was not what Midfield told him he would have posted that here as an update.

I know for a fact ,both Dr. Armstrong and Dr. Alley only recommend euthenasia as a last resort. They hate putting any animal down.

Georgie

Bessemer Alabama 


Billcoll01

MESA,
Arizona,
U.S.A.
2 THINGS

#5Consumer Suggestion

Fri, January 18, 2008

1 ITS NICE TO SEE SOMEONE ON HERE POST A RETRACTION ON A MISTAKEN POST. I SEE TOO MANY BOGUS POSTS ON HERE WHERE THE OP SEEMS TO DISAPPEAR WHEN IT TURNS OUT THAT THEY WERE WRONG! THE IDEA OF THIS SITE IS TO EXPOSE BOGUS COMPANIES & SCAMS. WHEN PEOPLE MAKE A BOGUS ROR & DONT MAKE AN ATTEMPT TO RETRACT IT, THAT JUST HURTS THE PROCESS AS A WHOLE! 2 NO VET IS GOING TO TELL YOU TO PUT AN ANIMAL TO SLEEP UNLESS THEY ARE ABSOLUTELY SURE THAT IT IS THE BEST THING. DONT FORGET, ILLNESS CAN BE THERE EVEN IF NO SYMTOMS ARE OBVIOUS. THAT GOES FOR ANIMALS & HUMANS. ON THE OTHER HAND SOMETIMES THE SYMTOMS SHOW BEFORE TESTS CAN SHOW THE ILLNESS. MY GRANDMOTHER DIED OF LUNG CANCER 61 DAYS AFTER HAVING A CHEST X-RAY THAT SHOWED NOTHING ABNORMAL! WHEN SHE DIED, THE TUMOR HAD GONE FROM INVISIBLE TO BEING THE SIZE OF A FRAPEFRUIT!


Rich

Birmingham,
Alabama,
U.S.A.
A very positive update regarding midfield animal clinic/hospital to my original post

#6Author of original report

Thu, January 17, 2008

Okay, i believe in the original post i was going to give a update, so i am... About 2 months later, i returned to the animal hospital and stated, i paid for the services and instead of rendering the most reasonable services, but they refused on 8/1/2007, that was the original purpose of my visit nails cut back and he needs his shots, but instead the 2'nd veternarin G. Kent Armstrong refused to comprimise in any way and stated i would have to take them to court, then the police appeared. And i told the police why i attempted to work out a comprimise... being someone who never has been a person participating police involvement i complied... certainly not worth that for $85.00 But it became apparent about a month later what the original veternarin of Midfield Animal Clinic who is Rodney Alley began to become apparent. on 8/1/2007 when i originally brought my dog in, it appeared to me as minor heat exhaustion, a minor injury he was recovering from, he needed his shots, nails cut back, and a general exam. As originally posted he refused to render these very reasonable service and instead stated spinal demyelination and arthritis, end age, at the most weeks and not months. I didn't reconize any arthritis just a older overall healthy dog. However at the beginning of 11/2007, the ability for this dog to get back up was worsening.. finally on 11/15/2007 i consulted with another vet stating again the arthritis. This time i did considerably farther research and learned what the midfield animal clinic most likely originally stated was accurate... on 11/23/2007, suffering became apparent and infact it was true, a dog with a good healthy coat, other than what appeared as simply slipping on overgrown hair, i had to put him to sleep. Reflecting back, i have to honestly state what Rodney Alley DVM at the Midfield Animal Clinic stated was most likely a very accurate diagnosis. I now realize that starting about a year ago, this dog most likely was not slipping on overgrown hair covering the pads, but displaying acute collapsing. I understand the demyelination was proably related to being bit by another dog about a year before that, i don't know for sure whether i believe it's spelled encephalitis. However by the beginning of 11/2007 it became very evident this dog was displaying neurological end stage symptoms and paralysis of the hind legs was rapidly approaching. By the middle of 11/2007, i got one final diagnosis which was not nearly as accurate/complete as the midfield animal clinic, then realized indeed the demyelination was rapidly leading to paralysis and unless i choose to address a very expensive neurological specialist i considered the inability to walk without no, not related to slipping on hair covering the pads, but indeed were acute more like chronic collapsing indeed had occured for close to 1 year, that was it. I'm really sorry about my original post, as stated overall this dog did appear healthy on 8/1/2007 when i requested the most reasonable services, but Rodney Alley DVM refused instead to state what was not yet apparent. 3 Months later, what he stated became quite apparent I began to research demyelination, i believe encephalitis and related neurological issues and within 2 weeks this dog was very close to paralysis in the hind legs. I now realize on the date i am posting this most likely what appeared as slipping was most likely acute collapses So yes... the Midfield Animal Clinic is a really good animal hospital, Rodney Alley DVM really is a professional in the field, even though it did take some months for his diagnosis to become apparent. I only wish i could edit the original post, but that is not possible so at least i want to update the post, so i am Yes, i would honestly say i most definitely would recommend these Veternarins

Reports & Rebuttal
Respond to this report!
Also a victim?
Repair Your Reputation!
//