I should have known had I done my research first, but I didn't.
When I first asked via the online email submission about whether or not these bargain jeans were new or used, the email reply came with a gmail domain. This should have been my sign.
I as told the size jeans I was looking at were available and new. He did mention they had both new and "vintage", to be fair.
I orders two pairs. When they came, not only were both extremely used, one had a small hole in the a*s area. That pair had a horrific stench of cigarette smoke.
When you Google map the address of the business you can clearly see this is a house, not a legitimate business site.