Complaint Review: The Puppy Shoppe/Bahuaka Inc. - Venice Florida

When Mary Ellen Whitehead's dog died of illness, she would have blamed misfortune had it not been for one major detail: It had happened before, under eerily similar circumstances. Whitehead paid $897 in July 2004 for a Havanese-poodle mix from the Puppy Shoppe, one of a chain of pet stores that closed after the owner, Janice Lee Cabezas, was arrested in 2004. Charges were later dropped. Cabezas, 49, of Parrish, who had stores in Bradenton, Venice and North Port, was arrested again on July 26 on felony charges of scheming to defraud customers of more than $50,000. Cabezas pleaded not guilty on Aug. 2. Her next court date is scheduled for Sept. 2 in the Sarasota County Courthouse. In a probable cause report, Sarasota County Sheriff's Office Detective Jim Klay wrote that "animals were given false papers to inflate their value and sold to unwitting victims." Authorities believe that Cabezas gave customers false pedigree papers. As a result, they allege, customers paid up to $1,000 for what they thought were pure-bred or designer dogs that really were mutts. Detectives also allege that Cabezas forged documents, including vaccination forms and warranties, costing her customers thousands of dollars, according to a probable cause report filed by the Sarasota County Sheriff's Office in May. For a month, Whitehead, 39, said she spent hundreds of dollars on veterinary visits, trying to figure out what was wrong with her dog, whom she named Havana. On Aug. 13, 2004, Whitehead and her two children watched as the 18-week-old puppy convulsed from seizures and yelped in pain. Because of Hurricane Charley, no veterinary offices were open, Whitehead said. The dog died the next day. Seven years before, Whitehead had purchased another dog from Cabezas' store. Four years later, that dog also died from a chronic illness. Whitehead chalked up her first dog's death to bad luck, not suspecting that something was wrong at the Puppy Shoppe. But two dead dogs from the same store were too many. Whitehead, a stay-at-home mother, decided to investigate. She sent Havana to the University of Florida's veterinary school for an autopsy. A week later, the results showed that Havana died of distemper, a rare, contagious disease typically prevented by vaccinations. Whitehead, who paid $100 extra for a warranty on Havana, went to Cabezas to warn her that her shop could be carrying the disease. But Cabezas refused to refund Whitehead's money, and blamed her for subjecting the dog to distemper, Whitehead said. "She said, 'I do not, nor have I ever, had an animal in my kennel spreading disease,'" Whitehead recalled. Whitehead started poking around local pet stores, asking questions and leaving her phone number in case someone with similar experiences dropped by. Within days, Whitehead's phone began to ring. "I started to get a flood of calls from people saying, 'I've had a problem with this store,'" Whitehead said. Now, Whitehead has a notebook full of names and phone numbers of customers whose dogs became sick, or died. On Aug. 30, 2004, Whitehead met with sheriff's personnel. Her complaint was among 134 filed with the Sarasota County Sheriff's Office by customers who purchased dogs from Cabezas. Some of those dogs died. Others lived, but were frequently sick. On Sept. 27, 2004, sheriff's deputies searched Cabezas' Venice store. They seized "numerous documents that were questionable," according to the report. According to the report, many victims were denied refunds, though they had purchased warranties. In October, deputies arrested Cabezas on 16 misdemeanor counts of failure to possess veterinary health certificates for animals for sale. The state attorney's office later chose not to prosecute her on those charges. But detectives continued to investigate Cabezas for fraud. "It's my understanding that all the paperwork was in order, and everything was done according to the law and state and federal regulations," said Cabezas' lawyer, Donald Greico. It's uncertain whether Cabezas still works in the pet business. A phone number for her store, River Hills City Pets in Valrico, was disconnected. A phone call to a number for Cabezas, listed on a sheriff's report, was not immediately returned. Cabezas' accusers credit Whitehead for the progress so far. She has every phone number she needs written down. She knows what's happened so far, and what can be expected to happen next. "She knows a lot more about it than I do," said John Ferrazzano, who lives in Manatee County. A dog he purchased in February from Cabezas' Bradenton store died from liver problems. "She's a detective and a half," said Barbara Kinney, whose pet, purchased from Cabezas, also died. Whitehead, who has three other dogs, still keeps Havana's ashes at home. She said she's not ready to bury her dog yet. "I haven't been able to bring myself to bury her," Whitehead said. "I don't feel like there's been resolution yet." Source: Herald Tribune - Aug 9, 2005

James, I understand what you are saying, but you do understand that without breeders selling to this pet store there would be not be a problem? No responsible breeder would sell companion animals to a company that puts their breed in harm's way. Stop the irresponsible breeders, stop the pet store. And I encourage you to keep up the battle. Putting an end to this kind of abuse is very important. Kay, No, I am not a "member" of PETA although I do applaud them for their work. As far as breeds that come from shelters: Doberman Pinschers, Akitas, Chows, Labs (purebred), Retrievers (purebred), Basset Hounds, Beagles, Domestic Rabbits (purebred), Cats (purebred), Hamsters, Guinea Pigs, Domestic Rats, Domestic Mice, Cockateils, Parrots, Canaries, Parakeets, and the list goes on and on. There are mixed breeds by the thousands. Do you think the stork dropped them off at the shelter's front door? Or was it irresponsible breeding? As far as "excuses" for people dumping their companion animal, here's a few: "We just retired and we want to travel. We have two dogs, but we don't want the 10 year old anymore. We'll keep the 8 year old." (You didn't think of that BEFORE you got these dogs?) "We just bought a house that backs up to a golf course and our 7 year old dog is too big." (Don't buy a house that backs up to a golf course.) "I didn't know having a dog would take so much time and energy." (You've had the dog for 3 years and you just now figured that out?) "The dog keeps biting my son." Me: Your son is 3 years old. You should crate the dog while you aren't supervising them. "I do crate the dog". Me: Then how is the dog biting your son? "My son keeps sticking his hand in the crate." Me: Either take your son to obedience school or get rid of your son and keep the dog." When someone has had a dog for more than a year, I have trouble seeing their side in situations like I just explained. This is just the tip of the iceberg. You should also know that our rescue groups send people to shelters to adopt animals like those we have in foster care because that keeps one more animal from having to be killed (not euthanized, killed, euthanized much too clean and tidy of a description). I assume if you breed that your contract with the buyer states they are to return the dog to you in the event they no longer want the dog. And I assume that you use a microchip that can be traced back to you in the event one of your dogs is dumped and ends up in a shelter. And don't tell me it's too expensive. All Dobermans coming into rescue have a microchip and we have a written contract with the person who adopts stating the dog is returned to us if it is no longer wanted. Period. To Rich, Thank you from the mixed breed world. I agree that mixed breeds are wonderful and you have less chance of having the same diseases that come from certain breeds in a mixed breed. With your outlook, you should be involved in rescue (if you aren't already). I am not in rescue for the money (there isn't any except my own money going out the door). I am in rescue to put an end to mass destruction of the animal kingdom. If they aren't irresponsbily bred they won't die a horrible death later, whether it be in a pet store with no morals or a shelter or on the street. I had my daughter read your line about "putting children on the same level as animals". She is still laughing. Our adopted animal companions are her brothers and sisters. She wouldn't have it any other way. She is an adult and spends as much time rescuing and caring for the rescues as I do.

James, I understand what you are saying, but you do understand that without breeders selling to this pet store there would be not be a problem? No responsible breeder would sell companion animals to a company that puts their breed in harm's way. Stop the irresponsible breeders, stop the pet store. And I encourage you to keep up the battle. Putting an end to this kind of abuse is very important. Kay, No, I am not a "member" of PETA although I do applaud them for their work. As far as breeds that come from shelters: Doberman Pinschers, Akitas, Chows, Labs (purebred), Retrievers (purebred), Basset Hounds, Beagles, Domestic Rabbits (purebred), Cats (purebred), Hamsters, Guinea Pigs, Domestic Rats, Domestic Mice, Cockateils, Parrots, Canaries, Parakeets, and the list goes on and on. There are mixed breeds by the thousands. Do you think the stork dropped them off at the shelter's front door? Or was it irresponsible breeding? As far as "excuses" for people dumping their companion animal, here's a few: "We just retired and we want to travel. We have two dogs, but we don't want the 10 year old anymore. We'll keep the 8 year old." (You didn't think of that BEFORE you got these dogs?) "We just bought a house that backs up to a golf course and our 7 year old dog is too big." (Don't buy a house that backs up to a golf course.) "I didn't know having a dog would take so much time and energy." (You've had the dog for 3 years and you just now figured that out?) "The dog keeps biting my son." Me: Your son is 3 years old. You should crate the dog while you aren't supervising them. "I do crate the dog". Me: Then how is the dog biting your son? "My son keeps sticking his hand in the crate." Me: Either take your son to obedience school or get rid of your son and keep the dog." When someone has had a dog for more than a year, I have trouble seeing their side in situations like I just explained. This is just the tip of the iceberg. You should also know that our rescue groups send people to shelters to adopt animals like those we have in foster care because that keeps one more animal from having to be killed (not euthanized, killed, euthanized much too clean and tidy of a description). I assume if you breed that your contract with the buyer states they are to return the dog to you in the event they no longer want the dog. And I assume that you use a microchip that can be traced back to you in the event one of your dogs is dumped and ends up in a shelter. And don't tell me it's too expensive. All Dobermans coming into rescue have a microchip and we have a written contract with the person who adopts stating the dog is returned to us if it is no longer wanted. Period. To Rich, Thank you from the mixed breed world. I agree that mixed breeds are wonderful and you have less chance of having the same diseases that come from certain breeds in a mixed breed. With your outlook, you should be involved in rescue (if you aren't already). I am not in rescue for the money (there isn't any except my own money going out the door). I am in rescue to put an end to mass destruction of the animal kingdom. If they aren't irresponsbily bred they won't die a horrible death later, whether it be in a pet store with no morals or a shelter or on the street. I had my daughter read your line about "putting children on the same level as animals". She is still laughing. Our adopted animal companions are her brothers and sisters. She wouldn't have it any other way. She is an adult and spends as much time rescuing and caring for the rescues as I do.

James, I understand what you are saying, but you do understand that without breeders selling to this pet store there would be not be a problem? No responsible breeder would sell companion animals to a company that puts their breed in harm's way. Stop the irresponsible breeders, stop the pet store. And I encourage you to keep up the battle. Putting an end to this kind of abuse is very important. Kay, No, I am not a "member" of PETA although I do applaud them for their work. As far as breeds that come from shelters: Doberman Pinschers, Akitas, Chows, Labs (purebred), Retrievers (purebred), Basset Hounds, Beagles, Domestic Rabbits (purebred), Cats (purebred), Hamsters, Guinea Pigs, Domestic Rats, Domestic Mice, Cockateils, Parrots, Canaries, Parakeets, and the list goes on and on. There are mixed breeds by the thousands. Do you think the stork dropped them off at the shelter's front door? Or was it irresponsible breeding? As far as "excuses" for people dumping their companion animal, here's a few: "We just retired and we want to travel. We have two dogs, but we don't want the 10 year old anymore. We'll keep the 8 year old." (You didn't think of that BEFORE you got these dogs?) "We just bought a house that backs up to a golf course and our 7 year old dog is too big." (Don't buy a house that backs up to a golf course.) "I didn't know having a dog would take so much time and energy." (You've had the dog for 3 years and you just now figured that out?) "The dog keeps biting my son." Me: Your son is 3 years old. You should crate the dog while you aren't supervising them. "I do crate the dog". Me: Then how is the dog biting your son? "My son keeps sticking his hand in the crate." Me: Either take your son to obedience school or get rid of your son and keep the dog." When someone has had a dog for more than a year, I have trouble seeing their side in situations like I just explained. This is just the tip of the iceberg. You should also know that our rescue groups send people to shelters to adopt animals like those we have in foster care because that keeps one more animal from having to be killed (not euthanized, killed, euthanized much too clean and tidy of a description). I assume if you breed that your contract with the buyer states they are to return the dog to you in the event they no longer want the dog. And I assume that you use a microchip that can be traced back to you in the event one of your dogs is dumped and ends up in a shelter. And don't tell me it's too expensive. All Dobermans coming into rescue have a microchip and we have a written contract with the person who adopts stating the dog is returned to us if it is no longer wanted. Period. To Rich, Thank you from the mixed breed world. I agree that mixed breeds are wonderful and you have less chance of having the same diseases that come from certain breeds in a mixed breed. With your outlook, you should be involved in rescue (if you aren't already). I am not in rescue for the money (there isn't any except my own money going out the door). I am in rescue to put an end to mass destruction of the animal kingdom. If they aren't irresponsbily bred they won't die a horrible death later, whether it be in a pet store with no morals or a shelter or on the street. I had my daughter read your line about "putting children on the same level as animals". She is still laughing. Our adopted animal companions are her brothers and sisters. She wouldn't have it any other way. She is an adult and spends as much time rescuing and caring for the rescues as I do.

James, I understand what you are saying, but you do understand that without breeders selling to this pet store there would be not be a problem? No responsible breeder would sell companion animals to a company that puts their breed in harm's way. Stop the irresponsible breeders, stop the pet store. And I encourage you to keep up the battle. Putting an end to this kind of abuse is very important. Kay, No, I am not a "member" of PETA although I do applaud them for their work. As far as breeds that come from shelters: Doberman Pinschers, Akitas, Chows, Labs (purebred), Retrievers (purebred), Basset Hounds, Beagles, Domestic Rabbits (purebred), Cats (purebred), Hamsters, Guinea Pigs, Domestic Rats, Domestic Mice, Cockateils, Parrots, Canaries, Parakeets, and the list goes on and on. There are mixed breeds by the thousands. Do you think the stork dropped them off at the shelter's front door? Or was it irresponsible breeding? As far as "excuses" for people dumping their companion animal, here's a few: "We just retired and we want to travel. We have two dogs, but we don't want the 10 year old anymore. We'll keep the 8 year old." (You didn't think of that BEFORE you got these dogs?) "We just bought a house that backs up to a golf course and our 7 year old dog is too big." (Don't buy a house that backs up to a golf course.) "I didn't know having a dog would take so much time and energy." (You've had the dog for 3 years and you just now figured that out?) "The dog keeps biting my son." Me: Your son is 3 years old. You should crate the dog while you aren't supervising them. "I do crate the dog". Me: Then how is the dog biting your son? "My son keeps sticking his hand in the crate." Me: Either take your son to obedience school or get rid of your son and keep the dog." When someone has had a dog for more than a year, I have trouble seeing their side in situations like I just explained. This is just the tip of the iceberg. You should also know that our rescue groups send people to shelters to adopt animals like those we have in foster care because that keeps one more animal from having to be killed (not euthanized, killed, euthanized much too clean and tidy of a description). I assume if you breed that your contract with the buyer states they are to return the dog to you in the event they no longer want the dog. And I assume that you use a microchip that can be traced back to you in the event one of your dogs is dumped and ends up in a shelter. And don't tell me it's too expensive. All Dobermans coming into rescue have a microchip and we have a written contract with the person who adopts stating the dog is returned to us if it is no longer wanted. Period. To Rich, Thank you from the mixed breed world. I agree that mixed breeds are wonderful and you have less chance of having the same diseases that come from certain breeds in a mixed breed. With your outlook, you should be involved in rescue (if you aren't already). I am not in rescue for the money (there isn't any except my own money going out the door). I am in rescue to put an end to mass destruction of the animal kingdom. If they aren't irresponsbily bred they won't die a horrible death later, whether it be in a pet store with no morals or a shelter or on the street. I had my daughter read your line about "putting children on the same level as animals". She is still laughing. Our adopted animal companions are her brothers and sisters. She wouldn't have it any other way. She is an adult and spends as much time rescuing and caring for the rescues as I do.

There is a serious criminal investigation going on here regarding this specific chain of pet stores and I think many of you are missing the point. I'm not trying to be rude when I say this but please take your debates about purebreds vs. mixed breeds or pound puppies vs. pet store puppies to a more suitable forum. This space should be reserved for people who have been victims of this store's venomous business practices. This company, which goes by many names including Fido's, The Puppy Shoppe, Bahuaka, Pups Inc. is under criminal investigation as a result of a serious Distemper outbreak of epidemic proportion. Many, many puppies died unnecessarily after suffering an agonizing fight for their lives only to be met by an excruciating death as a direct result of the criminal behavior of the owner Janice Cabezas and the Veterinarian Dr. Don Swerida. The victims of this company's fraud and corruption deserve JUSTICE!!!

If there were no dog breeders then the specific lines that many of us have come to adore would no longer exist...including "miniature dobermans" -AKA- Miniature Pinscher. FYI, This breed development predates the Doberman Pinscher by about 100 years, and therefore cannot be considered a miniature Doberman Pinscher. If you want a certain size dog, or a certain type of coat (short, silky, non-shedding), you can choose a purebred who has those characteristics.When you see a purebred puppy, you have a pretty good idea of what he will look like as an adult.To some extent, temperament is also "hardwired" into the genes of purebred dogs. With most dogs, there is always some hope that you can guide them into good behavior by raising and training them well, whatever their genetic make-up may be.But some purebred dogs have such strong genetic tendencies that nothing you do will have much effect. For example, some Akitas and Alaskan Malamutes will never tolerate another dog of the same sex, no matter how hard you try. Square peg round hole scenario. Good breeders are those who tests prospective parents for specific disorders before breeding them together has the breed's best interests at heart. Yes many show breeders are ego maniacs and I haven't met many that I can tolerate the company of for any large amount of time. To sum it all up, If you have two dogs, regardless of breed, and they have been tested and are free of genetic defects then yes these dogs regardless of whether they are poodle to poodle or poodle to cocker spaniel. You will have healthy puppies from this mating.Ergo you have had a hand in producing someones future pets that will have the potential to live a full and happy life.I have picked up "pound puppies" in my search for a perfect pet,when I was in my early 20's.One was a chihuahua, he developed seisures,low bloodsugar, diabetis,kidney failure and he met his end at the age of 2 years old due to a stroke. I did all I could and spent a good sum of money at the vet to save my "pound puppy". Its a heartbreaking thing to go through. Similar events have happened to dogs I and others I know have picked up in my rescue attempts. When purchasing from a "show breeder" check the pedigree for multiple use of the same names..this is line breeding. If it shows up more than 3 times within a 5 yr pedigree RUN AWAY. I do not like the AKC,for one reason (of many)in my opinion,they endorse puppy mills and big business commercial breeders. My breed of preference is the poodle,Having family members with allergy issues,I like the fact that they do not shed and have very very miniaml dander. Not that what I like pertains to anything of importance here,but I am thankfull that this particular "purebred" exists.

I don't believe that AKC or anyone involved with breeding animals cares one bit about animals in general. From what I've heard and read over the years, purebred dogs aren't any better than pound puppies. They often do get sick, suffer from diseases (often genetic), and don't appear to show any more love or affection than any other dog. Everyone involved in breeding or showing of animals has one of two reasons for their involvement, money, or ego. The ONLY pure reason for owning a pet is for companionship, to make them a member of your family, and to treat them as well as you would any member of your family, hopefully better. For most pets (especialy dogs) will be more loving, caring, and loyal than most family members. (Search for "dog's prayer) How can anyone justify creating a life when it will cost a life? For each animal that is bred, replaces that void that would otherwise be filled by an animal thrown away in an animal shelter. It should be a requirement that when you purchase a dog from a breeder, that you must first go to the local shelter, and watch an animal die, an animal that could have filled that void, cost a whole lot less, and been much more greatful to you for saving its life. The most wonderful dog I ever had was a pound puppy. I went to the local shelter hoping to find a lap dog, As I walked down the isle, I didn't see any that fit my ideal, but as I walked back this minature doberman looked at me and cried. I stuck my hand out, more to comfort her than anything, and she licked me tenderly. Those soft brown eyes stared at me, pleeding with me not to walk away... I didn't choose her, she chose me, and never a day went by that she didn't make me feel appreciated for saving her life. Instead of spending hundreds of dollars on an animal bred for profit and encouraging people to treat a life as a comodity, save a life and spend a fraction of the money you saved on obediance training (if they need it). You may not be chosen by a pound puppy on your first visit like I was, but when you are chosen you'll know that it's true love. And if after reading this you still feel that buying a dog is better than rescuing one and having them fixed so they won't breed more pound puppies, then please get yourself fixed so you don't have offspring of unpure lines that may grow up with your demented sense of values.

To:S.N. - Bucyrus, Kansas you stated"The main reason animals are dumped is NOT because of the animal,it's because of the person who had them." Give me a break...of course it has something to do with the person who had them ALSO.But I am correct when I say the majority of dogs that are dumped are INDEED problem dogs.I run a nonprofit breed specific rescue in my area..I am the only one within 300 miles,I patrol the local shelters.The majority of dogs are MIXED breed dogs. And the purebreds I have come across are usually (not always)very difficult to modify. IE: I rescued a young adult male cocker spaniel.I had him for 5 months,this dog bit me so many times...no warning just bit me,bit when I fed him bit when I pet him,dont even get me started on bath time.He seemed so sweet just to look at him, and he would wag his tail, but if anyone reached for him he would bite.This dog could not be placed.Then there was the dog that dug holes in the yard and ran away, the dog that destroyed everything in its path (chewing fences, four wheeler seats,cats etc)or the dog that would hold its urine all day until it came inside to urinate on everything in site.(couches,beds,etc) You also stated:"I'm sure that somewhere in your background there could be an inherited medical condition.You don't want to pass that along, do you?If the human child screws up during potty training are you going to dump it off on social services because it was "too much trouble"You must be a radical PETA member if you are putting dogs in the same classification as children.Truth is my son has epilepsy and no I did not drop him off at social services when I found out. But that is the difference in a CHILD and a DOG. you said:"From some of the complaints I have seen regarding breeders here you won't know the medical history of a purchased breed either." Yes some of the breeders in this world make very very unscrupulous decisionsin their breeding program.But many others are selective in their breedings.Of COURSE you would only hear of the complaints on breeder within THIS website..its called the RIP OFF REPORT because you report complaints not praise. Many other people KNOW what I am talking about...not many people want a $85 shelter dog to pee all over their $5,000.00 living room furniture.Wheres the enjoyment in that?You feel me now?I work with each individual dog for months and sometimes I get good results but sometimes it is fruitless.I have compassion,but I also have common sense.We as humans can only do so much. Humans like me are the reason shelters are full?Listen it is the humans like you that keep owners of "problem" dogs from seeking out breed specific recues, many people can't handle getting fussed at for surrendering a dog that they can no longer keep,for whatever the reason.Think before you speak.

I believe the reason you don't see as many purebreds put down in shelters is (1) Breed rescue groups monitor shelters and rescue the breed dogs if they can (2) not all shelter personnel know what breeds are what. I wholeheartedly disagree with your assessment of dogs in shelters (or any other animal left in a shelter for that matter). The main reason animals are dumped is NOT because of the animal, it's because of the person who had them. People purchase animals on a whim and then decide they are too much work or they didn't know they were going to be that big or they are moving and can't take the animal and so on and so on and so on. I work with different rescue groups and you wouldn't believe the calls we get. I assist in rescuing Doberman Pinschers. No dog comes in perfect but proper training, care and attention can cure those problems. You don't know their medical history? From some of the complaints I have seen regarding breeders here you won't know the medical history of a purchased breed either. Does that mean you aren't going to have any human children? I'm sure that somewhere in your background there could be an inherited medical condition. You don't want to pass that along, do you? If the human child screws up during potty training are you going to dump it off on social services because it was "too much trouble"? There is nothing that makes me angrier than a female who can act like this. Compassion obviously isn't one of your better traits. Humans like you are the reason shelters are full.

First I would like to respond to a few things that CHAD stated he said"AND 10 million animals die each year in the shelters of our nation. Don't add to that number by breeding your dog." How daft is that! The majority of pets in animal shelters today ARE NOT purebreds. A study conducted in California, by the Peninsula Humane Society came to the conclusion that less than 1/2 of 1% of animals euthanized in shelters are purebreds. Purebred dogs left in animal shelters are usually there due to behavioral problems or as a last resort due to owners moving to a new address that does not allow pets. *If you DO NOT intend to breed your dog, you should have the animal spayed or neutured to avoid "accidental matings" that DO indeed add to the dog overpopulation problem. * So for the comment that CHAD said "and remember to adopt from a shelter or rescue next time" I would like to mention that yes you "could" find a nice pet from the shelter, but do you know these dogs medical history? No you do not. You may start off paying very little for a pet but in the long run you could end up paying thousands in medical bills.Not everybody wants a mixed breed dog from a shelter, not everyone wants to deal with a nuisance barker,a biter, fearfull dog, one prone to constant submissive urination etc etc... pick a reason, there is a reason this dog is in the shelter. What do you think it is? The dog was placed in a shelter because she was so sweet, beautiful, and loveable with a wonderful temperment so the owners felt the need to throw her away? I think not. Petstores, I thought everybody knew by now never to purchase puppies from a petstore, bird feed yes, goldfish yes...but puppies and kittens..no no no. And to Kim who stated "Most people would probably would like to get a dog from a local shelter, unfortunately there is not much demand for a pit bull, chow, or rottweiler mix" I say AMEN! I would also lik eto mention to Melinda that AKC registration does not ensure quality. I have seen some beautifyl dogs that are registered CKC and DRA and they are stunning.

Dear Mel, Did you forget to Mention the $1000.00 they gave you Plus The Beautiful Champion Sired Havanese puppy That they gave you to replace your Mixed Breed Puppy That Died. Also Did you Forget to Mention That The Picture That You Show Every One Of Havana your Dog That Died is Really a Picture of The Havanese That They Gave You That is alive and well. and by the way do you tell people how long you had Havana before she passed away. (Distemper has a 14 day incubation period)

Just to clarify,
I have purchased a total of THREE dogs from Bahuaka, The Puppy Shoppe, Fido's, Pups, Inc. (whatever they are calling themselves THIS week). My Wheaten did in fact die just as Jill said, my Shih Tzu is still with me.

The puppy (Havana) that I purchased in June died just as Jill said in August on the day of Hurricane Charley. Havana's death from Distemper is what prompted my investigation into the store and when I found out her death was not an isolated incident (there have been over 20 puppies die between June and August from Distemper)I turned my information over to Sarasota Sheriff's Office Criminal Investigations Department and they have done an outstanding job of putting together a solid case (the details of which I can not elaborate on because the investigation is ongoing).

To Melinda, and others who have bought puppies from Bahuaka Inc, aka 'The Puppy Shoppe':

It has now been proven the the owner of this store, and two others like it, is indeed part of a puppy mill ring. Having a friend that has bought FOUR dogs from the store (I'm not saying that she has much common sense in doing so) has so far had two die. One, a Wheaton Terrier had to be euathanized, due to a serious bowel problem, deemed unfixable by the vet.

The other, a Habanese-Poodle cross, died of distemper, something that is UNHEARD of nowadays, due to vacinations.

The owner devoted herself fully to the 'taking down of' this ring of stores, and for three months took phone calls, mail, ect. from people who had bought puppys from any of the three stores, worked near or in the stores, you get the picture.

She filed a legal case, SUED for the death of her two dogs, and went back to that same shop, and bought ANOTHER dog from the mill, bringing her total of said dogs up to FIVE. (Which would be three at the time, since two of them are deceased.)

Now, the police investigated. They found three dead dogs in the FREEZER, supposedly awaiting autopsy. But in the freezer? Why not in a certified vets' freezer? They also found many, many bozes full of criminal evidince against Bahuaka Inc.

Part of this evidence is that the numbers of the vaccinations of each and every dog are the same. They had been sharing vaccination needles, just stabbing the dog, and giving it some un-knowable amount.

Having another friend who lived down the street from the aforementioned owner buy a dog from Bahuaka Inc, an English Bulldog, They compared paperwork, and indeed, all the numbers were the same. Tank, the said English Bulldog, has breathing problems, usual for any kind of bulldog, but he still has to go in for breathing help from his vet. He is an otherwise healthy dog.

Just wanted you to know, ALL puppy stores are created equal. Their owners are usually buckets of scum, recieving sick and dying dogs from these mills, and not thinking another thing about them, just to make their own money.

One last FYI, I am thirteen, yet well-versed in the legal matters of this situation, being friends with the first woman I mentioned. Havana, the Habanese-Poodle cross that died, died in the woman's arms during Hurricane Charley, as they rushed it up to the pet hospital, near St. Petersburg.

DO NOT BUY ANYTHING FROM BAHUAKA INC, AS IT FUNDS A PUPPY MILL STILL IN THE RUNNING!!!

Please contact me via email or phone regarding complaints about this business. I can not elaborate as to the specific allegations of criminal conduct. However, I have a running list of victim's that I am compiling. I do not care where in Florida the transactions occurred - I will field all complaints.

Detective James Klay #1145
Sarasota County Sheriff's Office
Criminal Investigations Bureau
PO POX 4115
Sarasota, FL 34230-4115
941-861-1707
[email protected]

I bought a French Bulldog from their store in Bradenton for $1400.00. I, too, was given the "You'll get your A.K.C. papers in three months" spiel.

I purchased the puppy on 5/13/03. Here it is now 3/3/04 and still no paperwork. I have made numerous phone calls and store visits to no avail. The last time I was kicked out of the store with the threat of police action. I wasn't yelling or causing a scene. The staff simply didn't want other customers overhearing my criticisms. I was simply requesting that the manager, Lee Cabezas, speak with me. She refused.

I have contacted the local media. I received an E-Mail from WWSB, Channel 40, the Sarasota ABC affiliate. I was informed that they had already done a story critical of the business. I made a complaint through the Better Business Bureau. Bahuaka didn't even bother to respond to the complaint.

I have threatened leagal action. However, it most likely wouldn't be cost effective. My suspicions are that the dog is not a purebred as he doesn't look at all like a Frenchie based on the A.K.C. description. He weighs 35 pounds and A.K.C. states that Frenchies don't weigh over 28 pounds.

Any suggestions?

That you so much for your very informative response to the "puppy mill dilema"..... Here's the final response to those of you who are so very concerned with this situation........ My little Westie, now 13 months old was found to have a kidney problem, and so I have had her spayed.....See, I am a responsible pet owner!!!! Contrary to what some of you people may have THOUGHT!!!!!! I still love my little girl, and we have enjoyed attending basic and advanced obiedience classes.Also ,she has earned her CGC certificate......We will see what else is available for her when I feel she has had enough time to recoup from the surgery... I would never have allowed her to produce puppys that were not up to standard...............

I hate to say but ALL dogs purebred are show quality- but do they actually measure up to the breed standard set for that breed ? AKC does not discriminate on what is or isn't show quality- they will take your 22.00 entry fee for you to either walk out of the ring with a .25 cent ribbon or perhaps --NOTHING at all-- I have been showing for over 23 yrs, I have seen many so-called "show quality" dogs in my day , and I hate to say it ,but the proof is in the ribbons and points you earn. as for breeding that's a whole different ball game, you give up 4-5 months of your everyday life to raise a litter of pups, then even after they go on to their new homes are you going to do right by those creatures you brought into the world and GUARANTEE them for life against herediatry & congenital defects ? every responsible breeder DOES. and what happens if an owner decides after 3 years they no longer can keep the dog? are you willing to take that dog back and re-home it as a responsible breeder DOES ? If you have no clue on the background of the health issues with the parents,grand parents etc.. of your beloved dog , how can you put any type of guarantee on a litter of puppies ? a RESPONSIBLE breeder guarantees the dog for THE LIFE OF THE PET- not just 2weeks, 1 yr - but life- could you AFFORD an expensive vet bill if that dog ever becomes ill and you are SUED for selling a sick dog? there is alot to think about other than putting 2 dogs together and having puppies. and without even knowing the actual heritage of the dog ( as most pet shop pups aren't from quality stock) and medical behind the lineage of the parents you are setting yourself up for a big downfall. one way to check the "breeder" is go onto www.nopuppymills.com and there you can search for the breeder and see if they are a registered USDA puppymill, if so - then to break your BIG bubble- you have a nice pet who needs to be fixed beofre causing someone else problems with health & temperment issues !

Andrea, Thank you for your intelligent response to the puppy mill delima......I certainly can appreciate what you are saying......My interest is in improving upon the breed , and I have consulted with several breeders regarding my puppy; and have been told that she is "showable". I will be persueing this, and if in the near future it is determined that she is not "quality", I will have her taken care of.....I am a responsible pet owner.... I am also aware that in order to show my dog she must me intact....Again, if she is determined to be below standard she will be taken care of..And I will love her and cherish her as my companion, but until then, she will be given every opertunity to prove herself as a champion....... Again, I have to thank you for being so sensible in your response.............

Melinda,

Just because Chad is aware of and concerned with the plight of puppymill dogs and dogs that end up in the pounds, does not mean he has a sad life. It means he is aware of the sad lives suffered by animals who are bred and bought irresponsibly. I'm glad you love your puppy -- but there is no doubt that it came from a puppymill. Wait til you go to AKC shows to show your puppy and talk to dedicated, responsible breeders. Tell them where you got your dog and then listen to what they have to say.

Kim, No responsible or "classy" breeder would ever sell a puppy to a broker or directly to a pet store. "Classy" breeders want to make sure their puppies go to appropriate homes -- not just to people who can afford to pay or, more likely, have a credit card. Many people who buy puppies from pet stores do it impulsively, not after giving it a lot of thought and doing research on the breed they purchase.

Chad - only educated people like us understand what really goes on. As an intake person for a purebred rescue group, I know first hand that these puppy mill puppies end up in our hands after owner find out they have hip dysplasia and other genetic defects that will cost them thousands. HOW COULD YOU EVEN THINK OF BREEDING A PUPPY STORE DOG? Please before you do this, talk to a reputable breeder or someone from the local breed club of the same breed that you purchased. They can look at your dog and tell you if it is breed standard. Only dogs that better the breed should be bred. I would bet everything I have that the dog purchased from a puppy store should be bred. Please educate yourself before you make decisions that will affect others lives. I just adopted a dog from a rescue who was purchased from the Puppy Shoppe who has severe hip dysplasia (a genetic defect). It is affecting my life as well as my dog's life. At least have your dog's hips xrayed and sent in to OFA (orthopedic foundation for animals) before you breed your dog so that you don't pass on potential genetic defects to the puppies and have others go though the pain of a dog with defects. Your vet will know more about this. There is nothing wrong with getting a quality bred dog, but unfortunatly most these days aren't. A dog with AKC paperwork and an unducated owner are very dangerous.

Chad.........I guess you must have a very sad life, to waste so much time putting down someone you don't even know; or know anything about.

For your information, I am very much interested in showing my puppy with the AKC..Therefore, I needed the registration papers, and since in the contract it stated that this was part of the purchase price, I wanted what was due me....Can you understand that, or do you buy things advertised to do one thing and then get the old switcheroo.........

I am satisfied with the outcome of my situation, I have a beautiful puppy...with AKC papers, and I plan to show her...she has a good home, and ;for your information,I received her as a gift..not as a plan to manufacture puppies... Breeding her may have been a consideration,but not a definate thing,and,not to turn her into a puppy factory...I at the time I was very upset and wanted immediate action, so I may have written my comments to sound like that was my sole goal, but absolutely not mean't in that way..

I am a responsible pet owner, and have adopted many pets in my time......

Since my companion of 14 years,(a golden retriever,a rescue),passed away, my boyfriend knew of my interest and gave me the puppy..

Spend your time preaching to those who are truely animal abusers, and leave me to hell alone.... And get a life.........

You're right, Kim. Not everyone that breeds puppies is a puppy mill. However, I dare you to find us a puppy store that sells puppies that are NOT from mills and the like. Save your anti-PETA pro-animal abuse trash for those that care to send 10 million companion animals to their deaths in shelters each year. Compassion...it's in the dictionary. You can check into a definition online.

We're also very happy that Melinda can now go forth and have litter after litter of puppies to send more and more animals to their deaths. Way to go, ladies!

Unless you have a suggestion on how you can help this lady, save your PETA preaches for elsewhere. That is not what this website is intended for. Not everybody that breeds animals is a puppy mill when people spend a great deal of money on a dog, it generally is raised by somewhat classy people who love animals and care for them. Most people would probaly like to get a dog from a local shelter, unfortunately there is not much demand for a pit bull, chow, or rottweiler mix.

Melinda I'm glad your problem was solved.

Situation Resolved..... FINALLY; After 5 months of letters and phone calls my boyfriend and I are now satisfied that the Puppy Shoppe in Venice,Fl. worked with us to get the AKC paperwork in our hands.

It seems that there was a hold up at the corporate office.. Once that was resolved, we quickly were able to get our papers, as indicated in THEIR contract agreement...

That's all puppy stores sell. FYI, Bahuaka, Inc is legally located at 1509 S. Dale Mabry Hwy in Tampa. This is also a storefront for The Puppy Shoppe. Big surprise. And the United Pedigree Service? What? I think that you should enjoy the life you have with your wonderful pet, and remember to adopt from a shelter or rescue next time. And by all means, please spay her. Breeding a mill pup is only going to make things worse, AND 10 million animals die each year in the shelters of our nation. Don't add to that number by breeding your dog. Breeding is a selfish activity. If you insist, just to get an idea of what damage you'll do, go down to you local animal shelter and pick out 8 animals that you now get to kill, as that is, effectively what you'll be doing. It's sad that all you care about is your seeming inability to breed her and make some money. You love her like your child...would you breed them and then sell your grandkids?