Keith
Atlanta,#2Consumer Suggestion
Mon, August 10, 2009
I went through a similar situation with Stop and Shop Supermarkets. However, they collected the charges in a seperate transaction. So what I have learned, is if I want to pay with a Debit and/or a credit card, I pay at the teller, I tell them that I only want x amount of dollars worth of fuel, and that's what is charged. If you don't want to do that, then that's your own stupidity.
Larry
Phoenix,#3Consumer Suggestion
Sun, July 20, 2008
I used to process debit card transactions at a business I managed. When you swipe your debit card at a gas pump, the gas station has no way of knowing if you plan to buy one dollar or a hundred dollars worth of gas. Their system electronically sends an authorization request to your bank to verify that the account is legitimate and that there is enough money in your account to cover a sale. The authorization also places a hold on that amount of money until the sale is complete. In this case, Kroger requested an authorization for thirty-five dollars and you only had thirty. Even though the transaction was declined, your bank nonetheless showed a hold for thrity-five dollars. They probably charged you an overdraft fee. When you swiped the card a second time, your bank put you another thirty-five dollars in the red. The problem is that an authorization was requested, funds were held pending completion of the sale, but the transaction was declined and the hold was not cleared. Personally, I see this as a problem with your bank and not with Kroger. Kroger declined the transaction based on your bank's denial of an authorization yet your bank continues to keep the hold on your funds. I do not see where Kroger is at fault. The amount of the authorization is actually pretty low for current gas prices. Thirty-five dollars would not even put in half a tank of gas in my car. Most gas stations ask for a much higher authorization. My recommendation to anyone is do not swipe your debit card at the pump when you are low on funds in your checking account. The situation described here has happened to many others. If you do not have enough cash, hand your card to the clerk and ask for a specific dollar amount of fuel. This should avoid the over-limit authorization problem.
Mrtwobit
Murphysboro,#4Consumer Comment
Sun, July 20, 2008
I can understand why Kroger, and other companies, put a hold on an arbitrary amount of money when using a debit card at the gas pump. Without knowing how much gas you are going to buy they must verify that you have enough money for a fill-up. With today's gas prices that can easily be over $100. The problem really isn't the hold, but rather the length of time it stays active at your bank. I have already told my bank not to accept any transaction that will overdraft. Just deny the transaction. I do alot of online purchases so I purposely keep a low amount in my checking account. It's easy to see how a hold of $100 on a checking account can cause some serious overdraft problems. Not only only on the initial debit, but all incoming new debits that are overdrafted because of the hold. There needs to be a way of "instantly" removing the hold once the transaction is completed. (Like it was never even there!)
Anthony
Augusta,#5Consumer Suggestion
Fri, July 13, 2007
many store when you do debit with debit card you can be charged up to $5.00 just as you use a ATM from another bank and not your own when you go in a store like Target ,Kroger so on or pay gas instead of doing debit you slide card than push cancel than you see the tab that says credit push that most places when you use credit you sighn instead putting you pin in like a ATM and it's free it's like a credit card only that it come right out like ATM when you do debit and once you put your pin in theres going to be a charge most all store have to charge a fee because bank charge them for ATM/Debit credit you by pass it all just like if you use a debit card to pay a bill over the phone or order something it's being run like a creadit card and come right out of account in 24hr unlicke a credit card thats the only diffrance and you can't go over what you have in account depends on the pad the store has if you unsure let them know you want to do credit instead of debit some store only do cash are debit like grocey store ALDI they only do cash or dedit i have pay for gas at Kroger in Augusta GA at all 5 krgoers that have gas center and use dedit card but did it on credit and got my 10cents discount off with Kroger plus card so rember when you use debit card do it on credit
Bette
Decatur,#6UPDATE Employee
Fri, January 07, 2005
First, I would like to say that as a Kroger Fuel Center employee I am sorry that you had this experience with management. But, I work in a Fuel Center and you would be surprised the things people will come up with to get free gas. Recently, a lady came to my window and stated that she had pumped 22.00 worth of gas and the needle in her car did not move.(HA) The lady was very irate. I printed her receipt and informed her to report it to management in the store. Management gave her the 22.00 and she came and gave me 20.00 of it to put on the pump. She pumped 11.45 but did not return for her change. Which tells me she was too embarassed to come back and admit she was wrong. I could go on and on. I am with the others in saying you should contact your bank and have them reimburse your insufficient funds charges. Your card was declined at the pump because of your balance. If you had taken your card to the clerk and asked for under 30.00 worth of gas, the transaction would have went through because it is a SET amount. I have enjoyed my tenure with Kroger and feel that here, they bend over backwards to satisfy their customer...because after all, without customers, there would be no Kroger. I hope the bank refunds your charges.....
Isaac
Xxx,#7Consumer Comment
Sat, March 13, 2004
Krogers is a low rent sh*t hole. Krogers could give a d**n about charging your card twice , they are getting paid. Avoid them in the future. They are worst than Wal-Mart
Mike
Radford,#8Consumer Suggestion
Thu, February 05, 2004
Joe, your complaint is not with Kroger. The same thing would have happened at any gas station that has "pay at the pump." When you put a card into one of these pumps, the pump doesn't know how much gas you intend to buy. So it asks your bank for a fairly large amount ($35.00 in this case), enough to cover any typical purchase. When you turn the pump off, any excess money is returned to the bank. This happens everywhere, not just Kroger. Do not use a debit card in one of these pumps if your account balance is low. Some gas stations try to pre-authorize $100 or more. So the Kroger pump computer tries to see if you have $35.00, and your bank's computer answered "There's not $35.00 in this guy's account" (which was true), so the pump's computer says "OK, no gas for him then." Of course many people would have understandably did what you did, saying "Hmm, I thought I had $30 in there" and try again. Computers being what they are, the same process got the same result. The key point here is that Kroger didn't get $35, not once, not twice, not at all. The only money Kroger got is what you paid in cash, which they of course deserved because they sold you that much in fuel. So this situation is NOT a rip-off by Kroger, although their customer service people should have done a better job explaining it. Now over to your bank. You should go there and ask your banker pointblank whether his or her bank ever gave Kroger $70, or even $35, in fact ANY sum of money over this transaction. The answer is of course "no" as both sides have already admitted. Then you ask them if they didn't give Kroger any money, how could your account have become overdrawn. They shouldn't have to think about this too long; immediately DEMAND a refund of the two NSF charges that they're still trying to stick you with. Banks love to overcharge people who keep a low balance because it's the only way they'll make any money off of them. Sure they want to do whatever they can to discourage people from running accounts into the red and then leaving town, but charging $22.50 for a few microseconds of computer time is ridiculous. The debit card makes this process all too easy. Debit cards are NOT your friend if you live close to a zero balance.
Dreamscapes
Cincinnati,#9UPDATE EX-employee responds
Wed, February 04, 2004
I am a former employee for Kroger (in many states and many different departments). You are assuming that everyone who uses a debit card would be faced with these charges. I hate to be the one to inform you that you are sadly mistaken. I use a debit card all the time and have never encountered anything remotely close to what you are describing. There must be a reason why the store manager didn't believe you (especially if you had proof). Did you consider calling Corporate Kroger? They are located on Vine Street and Court St in Downtown Cincinnati. If calling didn't work, did you consider driving the short distance from the store in question to the corporate office? Have you considered taking them to small claims court in Hamilton County? There are many avenues to pursue at this point, and many unanswered questions. But, to sit and generalize that this happens to EVERYONE who uses a debit card or any other kind of card funding to pay for FUEL (yes, the u comes before the e in fuel) is ludicrous and uncalled for. Also, if you are using a debit card that is attached to your bank account, then there would have been NO WAY for you to become overdrawn, as debit cards reaching their max would not allow the payment to go through! Now, if your debit card had "overdraft protection" on it, it would allow the charges to go through with one exception. It would not overdraw the account and put it in a negative status, it would charge the overage to your credit card.