Jeff
Columbus,#2UPDATE Employee
Sun, March 09, 2003
I am a Dish Network dealer in Ohio and Kentucky. While I'm not the dealer that the customer dealt with, I may be able to provide some insight into this situation. It seems to me that Chanseok's problems started when he wasnt able to take the Dish with him to his new apartment. Thats his first mistake right there. Per FCC laws, no property owner can refuse to allow you Dish Network (or any other mini satellite) service on their property. They can, however, refuse to let you attach the dish to their building, in which case you can do a non-permanent installation (in some cases as simple as a bucket filled with concrete and a pole). When you tell the property owner about your plans to do this, and assure them that if allowed, your dish will be professionally installed, they give in 99% of the time and let you attach it to their building. But in all reality, thats neither here nor there. The customer signed a 1 year contract for service, and Dish Networks contracts are pretty ironclad. The same way if you were to get DSL service through your local phone company, you sign a 1 year, if you decide you dont want it, or for some reason, you can no longer use it (i.e. your computer breaks) you are obligated to pay for it, as you recieved a promo value to sign the contract. Another comparison is cellular service. You sign up for a 1 year, and move somewhere out of that carriers service area, you are still obligated to that 1 year, otherwise these contracts would be pointless, as unscrupulous (cellular or dish) customers could just say they are moving if they decide they want out of their contract. The last point that was brought up is that he got charged for the equipment on his credit card by the dealer. Plain and simple, he didnt return his equipment, which unless he paid for it up front, is stated very openly to be "loaned" equipment (similar to a cable box), or it becomes the customer's after completion of the initial contract. The way this works is that even though the end user gets the system for free in most cases, the dealer pays for the equipment from Dish Network. Once the system is sold and activated, Dish cuts a check to the dealer for his commission, plus the price of the equipment. If within a certain period of time (day 3 to day 230) the customer deactivates for any reason, Dish charges that amount (equipment + commissions) back to the retailer, and if the end user still has the equipment, the dealer is left holding the bag for around 2-3 hundred dollars, not to mention whatever he paid the installer, so most dealers have it plain as day in their contracts that if the customer deactivates in the first year, that regardless of what Dish Network charges them, they will also be assessed a charge for the price of the equipment if not promptly returned. I, personally, think that this customer was treated very fairly seeing as he didnt live up to the terms of the contract he signed, was not charged the entire cancellation fee, and didn't return the equipment. Sorry I got a little long-winded here, but I hope I covered all bases.